British politicians better gear up for battle.
The House of Lords voted last night to amend Justice Secretary Jack Straw's "gay hate law," which offers strict sentencing for homophobic remarks and actions that can be perceived as threatening. Many people, like Tory Home Secretary Lord Waddington, wonder whether such a law would trample freedom of speech.
When it comes to language touching on matters of sexual orientation, there has already been a load of trouble with the police misapplying the existing Public Order Act. It is our plain duty to try to prevent this continuing to happen.
The issue would be moot, of course, if people just got over the gays and minded their own business.
The House of Commons will now debate whether to push for Straw's original law or roll over for the higher Lords, who, according to The Daily Mail, "voted no-one should face jail for criticizing gay lifestyles or urging homosexuals to change their ways." And, surprisingly, we agree.
Sure, those ex-gays and "converters" are a pain in the ass, but can you imagine if they all went to jail? That we be half our editorial content – gone. Or, conversely, festering in prison, where there gay hate would only grow. Neither of these scenarios appeal to us.
Megan Phelps Picked Her 5 Most Hated Americans and None of Them Are Lady Gaga (19)
· zack says: Add my voice to questioning Queerty’s methods. There is a legitimate place for... »
The Maryland Church That Dares Accept Homos Is Drawing the Wrath of Catholic Leaders (9)
· B says: No. 8 ยท Peter wrote, “B just a thought or two:: I think Maryland is quite a distance... »
· Peter says: B just a thought or two:: I think Maryland is quite a distance from Rome Helping Gays IS... »
Lt. Dan Choi Has Been Called … Back to Service? (20)
· QueerToday says: Remember when the gay liberation movement used to be against war and militarism?... »
How Did a Company That Offers Health Benefits For Gay Partners Wind Up on HRC’s List of Worst Companies? (20)
· S says: Want to know where your HRC contributions go? According to the most recently filed form 990,... »
· Julien says: @Julien: edit: nonsensical »
· Julien says: @Mark: Your comment seems vaguely non-sensical. How does that statistic show that... »
Why Are There a Bunch of Naked Men Playing Baseball in the Library of Congress? (6)
· Rev. Steve says: Wasn’t that the design on the dishes in The Bird Cage? »
Old Spice’s Marketing Strategy: Make Fun of Men Who Act Femme (26)
· Same Crap says: Another queerty post FAIL. You guys can’t even manufacture fauxtrage properly. »
Are Ellen DeGeneres and Simon Cowell Already Feuding Before Idol’s Live Show Starts? (7)
· Simon Fan says: PLease. These are all lies and stupid weak rumors. They’re getting along fine.... »
As an adult, I think I can handle insults sent my way. As a parent, I reprimand any child who starts calling another child names or shows disrespect to an adult. If I am under physical assault, my primary concern is physical safety rather than the particular motivation for the attack.
I'm not a big supporter of adding hate as an extra crime or circumstance. My presumption is that no one is being assaulted because the assailant likes the victim. It is sort of implicit in violent attacks, isn't it?
I'm more scared of criminalizing "thought crimes" than I am of someone calling me a faggot.
Shouldn't PC Thuggism be discussed? Protection from violence or institutionalized discrimination is one thing…but verbal insults? Please…we'll have the goddam "Be Nice" mutaween on our hands if this continues unchecked.
I don't know how widespread "police misapplying the existing Public Order Act" is, but I personally know someone who asked the police for some data to resolve a question for an anti-bias policy her ministry was developing — and ended up being the subject of a police investigation for allegedly making a phobic comment (the question she'd been asked to research).
Over-zealousness even for a good cause is over-zealousness
This seems exactly to be the type of "special rights" that bigots accuse us of seeking… to implement this would just make gay people seem like whiners.