Christian: Zachary Quinto; Andy: Ezra Miller
This may be the darkest of all the 50 Shades casting potentials. Ezra Miller proved he has the depth to play a lost youth in The Perks Of Being A Wallflower but can he play a stubborn, sexually-innocent college student? Yes. It’s not totally hard to imagine his character growing up to be an Andy of sorts. Besides, he has an exotic look that would believably transfix Zachary Quinto. And then there’s Quinto, who practically defines handsome and brooding. While casting Quinto as Grey is wishful thinking, it totally works more than the idea of Matt Bomer.