“Gay” Murder In India
Indian police may have a gay panic case on their hands.
Coppers arrested 18-year old Kalpesh Patel this week for the murder of 35-year old Mohan Patel, with whom he has no familial relation. Kalpesh admitted to killing the older man, but claims he was simply defending himself from Mohan’s sexual advances:
On Monday night, Mohan asked him to accompany him to the Natraj theatre for some work. On finding a deserted place, Mohan asked him to have a homosexual relationship with him. On his refusal, Mohan threatened to kill him and even slapped and punched and later tried to rip his clothes. On finding no way to escape, Kalpesh took a stone lying on the ground and inflicted repeated wounds on Mohan’s head before escaping from the spot. Mahidharpura police inspector A R Desai said, “We have arrested Kalpesh. This teenage boy was forced to have a homosexual relationship with Mohan, who stays with his wife and children and works in the diamond firm in Katargam. During investigation we talked to some of the employees of Khodiar Krupa diamond firm and his friends and learnt that Mohan was into homosexual relationship with several [other] people.”
We can’t say whether or not young Patel’s telling the truth – we’re not psychic – but it would be a great motive: Indian law continues to marginalize the gays, a legal leftover from the colonial days.
Not knowing the details of the incident, it’s hard to make any judgements.
Rape is not necessarily fun, or even sexy and it does happen to men, by men . In fact, I’m suprized that it doesn’t occur more often. However, in order to protect their lives, I think that women are sometimes legally justified in killing an attacker. Why not men., if the siuation was that threatening.
As far as I know; it has little to do with an earlier Indian or British culture more related to the current extreme rightwing government implanted by America. 1/3 of our engineers are Indias. You can put any crude reality at the feet of modern american econ and politics.
Hitting someone once with a rock is self defense; caving their head in is murder–or overkill.