Queerty is better as a member

Log in | Register
picks

Is Trans B-Baller Kye Allums Being Silenced By George Washington University?

Kye Allums, a college junior, is supposed to be breaking down barriers as the NCAA Division I’s first trans basketball player, identifying as a man and playing on a women’s team at George Washington University, where he’s a point guard. But what began as a phenomenally open trans awareness effort that had Kye speaking openly about his experience has, according to her mother’s Washington Post interview, come crashing down — with Kye all but silenced and barred from the court.

Rolanda Delamartinez said in a phone interview that Allums – who has missed all but eight games this season because of two concussions – has been prevented from playing, even though she says he no longer has any symptoms from the concussions. She said Allums was told he would have to run for two hours straight to be cleared. “I know professional athletes,” Delamartinez said. “None of them had ever heard of anything like that.”

[...] Delamartinez claims a team doctor cleared her son to play two weeks ago. After Allums told his mother he had been cleared to play, Delamartinez made plans to fly to Washington to be at the game. Later, she received a text from her son saying the decision had been reversed by the trainer. “To my knowledge, no team doctor has ever cleared him,” Kvancz said. “The only thing I had ever heard was the doctor did not want to clear him, and that the concussions are a very, very big thing. “I never even thought of saying that person is not going to play because that person has a different belief than I do. That’s crazy.”

GWU’s athletic officials, however, deny Kye is being shunned for any discriminatory reason.

GW Athletic Director Jack Kvancz denied both accusations, saying the school’s first priority is to protect the health and eligibility of its student-athletes. [...] Kvancz said he was not aware of any two-hour running requirement and that Allums had not been able to complete satisfactorily a 20-minute run. “If he couldn’t get done the 20 minutes of running he had to do, it was going to take him another [several weeks] to get back in shape, why not pack it in [for the season]? And then try to get the young man ready to play when he was healthy,” Kvancz said. “Our concern is the health and well-being of the student.”

And then there’s the Oprah factor.

Delamartinez said her son wants to help other transgender athletes but school officials have refused to allow him to tell his story to reporters. According to Delamartinez, school officials told her and Allums not to speak to any reporters because the school had arranged to give an exclusive to Oprah Winfrey.

“Kye has conducted promotional activities, including numerous media interviews since November,” university spokeswoman Candace Smith said. “GW has offered Kye guidance and support on multiple fronts. At no time was the university involved in any discussion about compensation for any interview requests.” Kvancz said he had no knowledge of any agreement with Winfrey and that he told Allums to focus on academics and basketball during the season and to wait until after to do interviews and speaking engagements.

Can Allums juggle his school work, athletics, and trans advocacy? Of course. And while success on the court and in the classroom are certainly demanding tasks on their own, no university should be telling a student that his work in the community is somehow so trivial it can wait until after graduation. Rather, the perfect time for Kye to address his concerns, and talk about his experience playing college ball as a trans man, is when he’s in the thick of it. Don’t wait, Kye. We want to hear more.

By:           Ryan Tedder
On:           Feb 22, 2011
Tagged: , , , , , ,
  • 5 Comments
    • samthor
      samthor

      if one identifies as a man…. why play for the woman’s team?

      I’m asking because i do not know how to reconcile this in my own life? How do I answer the people who ask me this question?

      Feb 22, 2011 at 11:23 am · @ReplyReply to this comment ·
    • Sebastian
      Sebastian

      You have a pronoun error; please correct!

      “according to her mother’s Washington Post interview” should be “according to HIS mother’s…”

      Thanks for the article – very important

      Feb 22, 2011 at 11:48 am · @ReplyReply to this comment ·
    • TommyOC
      TommyOC

      1) Concussions are a big deal and schools are finally coming around on how under-treated they are. And if you’ve suffered two – playing basketball, no less – you won’t be cleared for some time. And you shouldn’t rush coming back anyway. Concussion number three starts entering retirement territory, so I hear.

      2) If you can’t run for 20 minutes, how are you going to play even if you were medically cleared from your concussions?

      3) What’s wrong with a school advising someone to emphasize their studies above all else? They’re called STUDENT-Athletes for a reason. And practically, to maintain athletic eligibility on and off the court, little time is left for you to do much else and still be a top-notch student-athlete.

      As for Oprah rumors and all that, this player should be careful to read his student contract. NCAA rules prevent him from sponsorship and paid activities, and I’m sure the school’s regulations have a couple regarding promotion as it relates to the program.

      Feb 22, 2011 at 11:06 pm · @ReplyReply to this comment ·
    • missanthrope
      missanthrope

      @samthor:

      Because he has a choice of either iving as a man and possibly taking testosterone, and getting kicked off the basketball team and losing his scholarship. Or he can can make a Faustian bargain and live as woman (which he probably isn’t happy about) and still be able to go to college.

      This is the type of unhappy bargains that many trans people have to make because there is no practical way to accomodate us, much more often no one willing to accommodate us. I’ve known some people who have had to put off transition or not transition at all for many reasons: family commitments, risking losing a job, or lack of access to trans-friendly health care etc.

      I’ve heard people ask why he might It probably take a couple of years of testosterone therapy have the muscle tone built up to even think of competing on a mens team, if he could play at all, he might be too short to be competitive on in men’s basketball.

      Feb 23, 2011 at 12:07 am · @ReplyReply to this comment ·
    • missanthrope
      missanthrope

      @missanthrope:

      Opps meant “I’ve heard people ask why he doesn’t play on a men’s team”

      Feb 23, 2011 at 12:10 am · @ReplyReply to this comment ·

    Add your Comment

    Please log in to add your comment

    Need an account? Register It's free and easy.



  • QUEERTY DAILY

     




    FROM AROUND THE WEB

    Copyright 2014 Queerty, Inc.
    Follow Queerty at Queerty.com, twitter.com/queerty and facebook.com/queerty.