My guess would be Michael Strahan from the Giants.

Sigh. Why can't it be Eli Manning? That would be nice -- he's pretty.

I got my money on a kicker or maybe a punter. How about Mike Vanderjagt? or Maybe one of the Cincinnati Bengals, I here prison can change a man.

I have no clue, but would love for it to be Peyton Manning. I've heard rumors about Peyton and Kenny Chesney for years. It would be especially ironic since Peyton's coach -- Tony Dungy -- recently spoke at a conference sponsored by an anti-gay group.

Sorry, manifold, but it's not going to be Peyton under this blind item. The Colts are an AFC team, not NFC.

jeff garcia??

First of all… when the Gold Club was going down in a blaze of fire in Atlanta for various sex-related reasons, there were a few “incidences” that came to light… including an Atlanta Falcon football player that loved (and apparently paid) to get off while having a vibrator up his ass. The name was never reviled though.

Also, with Atlanta… I always thought that Travis Hall was GAY GAY GAY… or at least extremely “metrosexual”… he’s now playing for the 49ers (also in the NFC). He would have no problem since (1) he’s not as young as he used to be and (2) he has other business ventures that can support him… so that’s my two cents.

Honestly, I have no idea but I'd love for it to be Thomas Jones of the Chicago Bears.

Ok, just googled Travis Hall. If it can't be Eli Manning or his BIG brother, then Travis would certainly be F-I-N-E with me.

I'd say Walter Jones of the Seattle Seahawks. I personally was his bitch for three years!:) Rock on Big Walt!