Recently Commented

Warning: include(/home/queerty/public_html/commented.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home/queerty/public_html/queer/news/valid-discrimination-20061207.php on line 105

Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening '/home/queerty/public_html/commented.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/local/lib/php') in /home/queerty/public_html/queer/news/valid-discrimination-20061207.php on line 105

RSS

Colophon

David Hauslaib
Editorial Director
David Hauslaib | Email

Andrew Belonsky
Editor
Andrew Belonsky | Email

Jossip
Publisher
Jossip Initiatives

— Thu, Dec 7, 2006 —
Valid Discrimination?
Churchies Argue For Christian Student Rights

rwilliams.jpg
For many people, college offers a space of personal liberation, a time when one can form and - more importantly - express their opinions. As you know, many gay people take advantage of the relative freedom to come out. Of course, not everyone's so keen on broadening their horizons.

Consider a case unfolding in England: a number of Christian organizations have been temporarily banned following accusations that they discriminate against non-Christians.

Needless to say this has caused a bit of a stir - most notably from Archbishop of Canterbury Dr. Rowan Williams (pictured with eyebrows) - who equate the bannings with a crack down on anti-nuclear protesters. Britain's The Times reports:

Christians on campuses across Britain are claiming that their right to freedom of expression is being challenged by student associations attempting to force Christian unions to allow anybody, regardless of faith, ethnicity or sexuality, to sit on committees and address meetings. The Christian unions say that they should be allowed to restrict committee membership to those who share their beliefs.

In his first intervention in the debate, Dr. [Rowan] Williams said that it was becoming impossible for traditional Christians and Muslims to state their views without being accused of something “akin to holocaust denial or racial bigotry”.


There's an important distinction to be considered: banning non-Christians from Christian meetings is not quite the same as propogating anti-gay rhetoric, a charge of which the groups have not explicitly been accused.

Williams goes on to say, “If disagreement is to be silenced because offence may be caused, that is not good for intellectual life." That's certainly a valid point, we think. A gay group, however, would most likely bar a homophobe from their meetings, so why shouldn't anti-gay Christians be allowed to ban people who disagree with their beliefs?

Any takers?

Comments


No. 1
Ryan says:

If the organizations are affiliated with *public* universities, they shouldn't be allowed to discriminate against who can and can't join.

If people from public colleges want to organize outside the parameters of being an officially recognized club within the school, that's their perogative, but they'd have to accept the responsibilities that go with being their own organization - which would include outside funding, finding places to hold meetings, etc. It can very easily be done as there's been dozens of small non-affiliated "clubs" at UMASS Dartmouth since I've been here. They don't receive school funding, but are easily able to figure things out and don't want to be burdened by the rules the school would demand.

Bottom line: organizations in public schools are funded through public money. Because that money is publically funded, anyone going to the school should be allowed to join if they wanted. Now, some organizations are naturally going to cater to people of the same mind - you don't find too many conservatives in Pride Alliance at my school (and the few who found themselves in it often got frustrated and left), similarly, I wouldn't ever join the Catholic Association... because, well, I stopped being Catholic years ago, don't agree with them and want nothing to do with that organization.

December 7, 2006 12:50 PM

Post Your Comments





Note: It may take up to a minute for your comments submission to be processed. Please do not click "Post" more than once, or your comments may be duplicated.



Email This Post

Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):


Advertisement
Welcome to Queerty. The gay blog.

Email your editors!
holla@queerty.com

Stereohyped

Promotion

Advertise on Queerty

Site Map