Queerty is better as a member

Log in | Register
 

Should Public Officials Shut Up?

When Maryland Governor Robert Ehrlich fired one of his Washington Metro transit authority board members for calling homosexuality “deviant” on TV, a brush fire of social controversy was quickly extinguished. Or was it?

On a public access program discussing gay marriage, board member Robert Smith said, “Homosexual behavior, in my view, is deviant. I’m a Roman Catholic.” Governor Ehrlich called Smith’s comments “highly inappropriate, insensitive and unacceptable.” All of which is true, perhaps, except that last term, as conservative Townhall.com columnist John Leo argues.

While Ehrlich was likely tossing out a string of adjectives that even we would have, Leo calls the governor on his “unacceptable” label.

Did he mean that all members of Washington-area boards are required to approve of homosexuality, or just that they must suppress any non-positive views during TV discussions of same-sex marriage? The governor, a Republican who is up for re-election and is trying to move from the right to the center, clearly hasn’t thought the issue through. He certainly seems to be banishing Smith for a thought crime. Perhaps he did so because he knew his Democratic opponents would come after him for tolerating “hate speech” if he let Smith stay on. Smith argues that his social opinions have “absolutely nothing to do with running trains and buses” and that they haven’t affected his actions or decisions on the board.

Maybe it’s not a good idea for government transit specialists to be pronouncing on divisive social issues. But they clearly have a right to do so. The Supreme Court says the First Amendment protects the right of public employees and appointees to speak freely on matters of public concern. So if Smith wants to sue over his firing, he seems likely to win. At any rate, liberals routinely argue that people should not be fired for behavior or speech unrelated to their jobs, such as professors who make loony remarks out of class, or schoolteachers who have children out of wedlock.

Now don’t think we’ve jumped over to the right wing; we haven’t. But Leo does raise a good point: Should we force our public officials to stay mum on their personal feelings, under the threat of firing, if they go against the grain? If they’re performing their job well, does it matter what belief system they subscribe to?

Yes, perhaps. Racist officials in charge of distributing funding to community groups could deny funding to black organizations. Anti-semetic officials in charge of assigning construction projects could skip over Weisberg Construction in favor of Botelli. But when it comes to homophobic officials, they’ve got one thing on their sides: sexual orientation is not yet a protected class.

GAYS HAVE EMERGED AS THE NEW PROTECTED CLASS IN AMERICA [Townhall]

By:           editor editor
On:           Jun 20, 2006
Tagged: , , ,

  • 1 Comment
    • dizzy
      dizzy

      Generally, I am a strong proponent of first-amendement rights. If a bus driver or telephone repairman wants to say homosexuality is deviant, more power to him.

      The difference is that politicians make policies we must all follow. They are in a somewhat unique position where their opinions are not just words but, i na very real sense, actions we must all deal with. If a council member says he disapproves of homosexuality its a de facto indicator of how he is voting and making policy. In this regard, Gov. Erlich was right to dismiss someone who pretty much state he would work to counter Erlich’s pro-gay policies (This is also true of teachers, to a lesser extent, whose opinions become lesson plans).

      Im a longtime new yorker but was born and raised in Maryland, which has been suprisingly pro-gay. (previous governor Paris Glendening was open about his gay brother and was a big supporter of gay rights and domestic partneships).

      Jun 20, 2006 at 2:24 pm · @ReplyReply to this comment ·

    Add your Comment

    Queerty now requires you to log in to comment

    Please log in to add your comment.

    Need an account? Register It's free and easy.

  • POPULAR ON QUEERTY

    FOLLOW US
     



    GET QUEERTY'S DAILY NEWSLETTER


    FROM AROUND THE WEB

    Copyright 2014 Queerty, Inc.
    Follow Queerty at Queerty.com, twitter.com/queerty and facebook.com/queerty.