As infuriating as Amazon’s decision to de-rank a wide swath of LGBT lit on the basis of it being ‘adult’ is and as unbelievable as their assertion that the problem was a ‘glitch’ is, actually seeing the books they’ve gone after is a whole experience entirely.
Amazon has consigned the gay canon to the status of ‘porn’, but they’ve done us a favor– a brief glance at the books they banned is a fantastic reading list of some of the great works of literature written by LGBT authors. A full list is here.
This is your heritage and your birthright and I don’t need to tell you that it ought to be defended. What follows are some of the books banned by Amazon. All of them are fantastic reads; go pick one up today, just not from Amazon.
The Book | Written By |
Why It’s Super Triple XXX Pornographic |
The Well of Loneliness |
Radclyffe Hall | This 1928 British class novel follows Englishwoman Stephen Gordon who always knows she’s a lesbian and finds love while working as an ambulance driver in World War I. It features the explicit plea, “Give us also the right to our existence” |
Heather Has Two Mommies |
Lesléa Newman | Newman was inspired to write this children’s book after a friend in Northampton commented there were no children’s books that showed a family that looked like theirs. It’s a popular target of conservative groups. |
Maurice |
E.M. Forster | Another class-based story of sexual awakening, Forster held onto his manuscript, leaving it with the note “Publishable, but worth it?” In 1971, the book was finally printed and eventually turned into a film. |
The City and the Pillar |
Gore Vidal | Famous for being one of the first novels to treat homosexuality as normal, it follows tennis player Jim Williams as he discovers his sexuality and fights in World War II. William F. Buckley famously called Vidal a queer, though Buckley’s dead and Vidal is still kicking. |
Giovanni’s Room |
James Baldwin | An American’s love affair with an Italian waiter is the set-up for the searing novel about alienation. Baldwin feared the novel would alienate him from his Black readership, but critics were too caught up in Baldwin’s brilliant writing to get angered by the homosexuality. |
Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit |
Jeanette Winterson | Winner of the Whitbread Award and often taught in British schools, it tells the story of Jeanette who is raised in an evangelical household who grapples with her lesbian identity, while submitting to exorcisms by her famly. |
Running With Scissors |
Augesten Burroughs | A bestselling memoir about Burroughs relationship with his eccentric mother who sends him to live with her psychiatrist. Burroughs winds up having an intense sexual relationship while he’s 13 with the psych’s 33-year-old son. |
The Front Runner |
Patrica Nell Warren | This 1973 novel is a classic of the gay sports genre (or any other genre for that matter). When three promising young athletes come to a coach for training, knowing he, like them is gay, none of them know where their relationship will lead. |
The Price of Salt |
Patricia Highsmith | Writing under the pseudonym Clair Morgan, Highsmith created a novel with all the elements of lesbian pulp, only the characters wind up with a happy ending, defying convention and enraging critics when it was released in 1951. |
Edinburgh |
Alexander Chee | Chee’s debut novel is a gripping account of how someone whose been molested as a child can overcome the violation of trust and hurt brought on by the molestation. Lyrical and filled with rich characters, Chee’s novel was hailed as an instant classic upon its release in 2001. |
The Book | Written By | Why It’s Super Triple XXX Pornographic |
dellisonly
Gore Vidal and Augesten Burroughs are porn? This is most definitely news to me! I always thought Amazon was the place to instantly buy anything. Guess I will buy from somewhere else.
bigjake75
Thanks for putting that list out!! I would like to see more and more features here listing sites, books, movies etc that come from out community.
Jamie
I’m not excusing Amazon here, but to say these books have been “banned” is ridiculous, and factually incorrect. They have not been banned. To characterize them as “gay books Amazon doesn’t want you to read” is equally ridiculous. If Amazon doesn’t want me to read “Giovanni’s Room,” how was I able to order it from them just a few months ago? All of these supposedly banned books are fully available and in stock. There is no censorship going on here, no banning.
There is absolutely nothing stopping you from purchasing any of these books. I don’t understand the ranking change either, and find it suspicious, but if you type in “James Baldwin” or “Edmund White” you will find pages of books, in stock, and definitely not banned.
This is very shoddy work, guys. There’s a legitimate issue here, one that needs to be investigated – by reacting this way, with objectively incorrect information and shrill exaggeration, you’re making it harder for us to be taken seriously on issues like these.
alan brickman
It’s become the “hot” new “book club” list for two book clubs of housewives already!!.. …Good work Glamazon!!!
DC Steve
@Jamie: nobody is saying they’ve been banned, only that they’ve been de-ranked and reclassified as “adult”.
It’s like the electronic version of that seedy back room behind the curtain at the video store. You can find what you want easily enough if you know what you’re looking for, but don’t expect to find it if you’re casually browsing the respectable parts of the store.
DC Steve
(whoops, just realized that the title article does use the word “banned”, and I agree that’s a questionable wording)
KLE
I’m usually pretty skeptical but thanks for the heads up. I will be shopping elsewhere.
I just went to amazon and searched for Running with Scissors. The DVD comes up but the book does not. When I searched for Heather Has Two Mommies, the 20th anniversary copy (which wasn’t available and had no picture) showed up at number 11…. not even close.
The glitch is Amazon got caught trying their own version of social engineering by further seperating out and hiding GLBTQ contnet. Someone flipped the switch or clicked a box, that categorized this as Adult. The glitch is human. There’s just no room anymore to tolerate this crap.
Stephen
For another take on the Amazon.com story:
http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Web-Services-Web-20-and-SOA/Amazon-Glitch-Strips-Rank-From-GayThemed-Books-147140/
Gggg
E.M. Forster is a CLASSIC!!!!! Take Lit 101, rednecks!!
Greg Ever
I think some of the books that I couldn’t search for and that got de-ranked yesterday are back today. One example, Unfriendly Fire, the new book about Don’t Ask Don’t Tell, had the info removed and you couldn’t find it via the main search function, but it seems to be back to normal now. I don’t know if that’s the situation for all books involved, though.
sparkle obama
in “running with scissors” the kid had a relationship with a guy who was “adopted” by the household or a lodger, right?
james baldwin’s “giovanni’s room” captivated me in high school.
i thought i was going to star in a film version starring me and keanu reeves, produced by madonna!
don’t laugh at me, it’s a hot book.
i even wrote a pop song about it in class, i recall.
well, they need to do it now.
cast diana ross’ son as the american
& zac efron as the italian.
music by adele, lenny kravitz & madonna, of course…
keanu reeves & kevin spacey as the Older Gay Men
J5
Don’t forget The Mask of Apollo! Awesome and historically accurate ancient Greek soap opera with Plato, Aristotle and Alexander the Greek as minor characters!
jim
@J5: and every other book written by Mary Renault, for that matter. Her collection is pretty phenomenal in a man-lovin’ kinda way.
Matt Z.
“This is your heritage and your birthright…” Those words gave me the chills.
Thanks, Japhy.
Jason in WV
James Baldwin? Seriously? Has Amazon lost its ever-lovin'(ever-hatin’) mind?
Earl Lee
@Jamie:
Like the Bible, Huck Finn and The Grapes of Wrath, these books are easily available in almost every library in the country. It is equally ludicrous to consider the book The Catcher in the Rye a “banned book.” Catcher has become such a popular mainstay of our culture that the recent film Conspiracy Theory rightfully presumes that every bookstore in the country has copies on hand for purchase. Obviously, it takes a certain amount of doublethink, if not outright hypocrisy to celebrate these books as “banned” in any way, shape, manner, or form.
The question is: If these books are not banned, then what books are? The answer is, of course, that with the notable exception of child pornography, few, if any, books are banned outright in this country. But many books *are* overlooked, ignored, sidelined and squeezed out of the marketplace.
Many small press books are unable to find a place in bookstores or libraries, thanks in large part to the efforts of big commercial publishers to hock their own wares at the expense of small press publishers. This form of commercial “censorship” is accomplished thanks to the libraries and bookstores that cooperate with the efforts of big commercial publishers to
“mainstream” our culture and marginalize dissent.