This article is in no way meant to imply RuPaul, the contestants on RuPaul’s Drag Race, or any of the editors, producers, PAs or key grips on the show are racist. That’s something only God and their hairdressers would know for sure. But, given the fact that the gay community is a microcosm of our country, it stands to reason problems like racism and discrimination are raised, dissected, and debated by our fair queendom.
With Drag Race being one of the most popular television shows by and for the LGBTQ community and their allies, there’s a lot we can learn about ourselves if we read between the lines. This season is arguably the best season in Drag Race herstory. It’s also boasts a top 4 who are all people of color. Despite this season’s apparent diversity, it also can show us some of the random bits of racism and bias we sometimes too easily take for granted every day.
RuPaul’s Drag Race is part commentary on reality television, part queer Super Bowl, part drag documentary and all inspiration by our own personal guru RuPaul. Or GuRuPaul, if you’re nasty. As marginalized and bullied people, it’s strange that we marginalize and bully others from time to time. Here’s hoping that by talking about these types of issues we can, “Snap out of it!” Chad Michaels are you there?
Here are 10 things this season revealed about racism within the LGBTQ community:
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
1.) No Fats, No Femmes, No Asians
Kim Chi is an accomplished artist, Instagram celebrity, and Drag Innovator. She’s done things with make-up that could flip your lace-front. But as she aptly pointed out in the “Shady Politics” episode, so many guys on Grindr and other hook up apps say things that are not just exclusionary, but pretty racist. Just because this phrase is an attempt at word play doesn’t mean it’s not discrimination. Sure people have their personal preferences but when you commit hand to keyboard it crosses the line from personal aesthetic preferences to a singular racist message. After all, some people have posted “We Don’t Like Gays” signs outside their businesses. Is there a difference?
2.) “You’re Hot for a Black Guy”
It’s sad to think that Naomi Smalls and Bob the Drag Queen are two of the hottest commodities in the gay world, but are considered hot in spite of something. Saying “You’re hot for a black guy” not only implies most black people are not hot it also implies a racial hierarchy. White supremacy exists in our culture but that doesn’t mean it’s right or we should encourage it. Yes there are a ton of white porn stars, underwear models, and celebrities vying for our attention. But many of them are also straight. That doesn’t make them any better than the attractive people of color. We should challenge our white standard of beauty, if only to give Lance Bass a break from all the attention.
3.) Ms. Derrick Barry, Poster Child for White Privilege?
People at times confuse white privilege for success or inherent advantages. But at its most simple definition, it’s that white people don’t always have to face the same challenges as people of color. Derrick even admitted during “The Grand Finale” he had never been challenged like this before. He’s a good-looking man and woman with not one, but two, attractive partners. He has a successful career that boasts a longtime Vegas run and America’s Got Talent credit. But it also seems like he practically walked into the top 5. Unlike former frontrunners Raja or Bianca Del Rio, it wasn’t necessarily based on an insane amount of talent. It just seems like he wasn’t called out for obvious offenses people of color had been judged for in prior seasons. For a queen in a drag competition to not glue down their brows and sew more than a seam seems insane. He delivered not one but three outfits built around a bathing suit. Former contestants like Joslyn Fox, Alissa Summers, and Venus D-Lite were sent home for outfits that had more work than Derrick’s. This is not an attack on Ms. Barry–who is very talented–but just a bit surprising that she was treated with kid gloves in the gauntlet of drag.
4.) ESL Does Not Mean Stupid
Most Americans do not speak more than one language despite our cosmopolitan culture. Hell, some Americans barely speak English. And yet, when people hear an accent they automatically think someone doesn’t get it. The editors sort of relish those moments when an ESL queen makes a funny turn of phrase or mispronounces a word. Throughout the season there have been moments where Cynthia Lee Fontaine or Kim Chi were caught unawares and given a shady edit. No T No Shade to the editors but they simply come from different cultures. Their pop culture references are different and while in the high stakes Hunger Games of drag they may not be thinking in English. As viewers, we must be sure not to underestimate people just because they have an accent.
5.) The Puerto Rican Problem
Most Americans don’t even know Puerto Rico is a part of the United States. They also don’t know the struggles the natives of this popular tourist spot face. There’s the overwhelming debt, poverty, and strange identity as a not-quite-State of the Union. Puerto Rico has helped drive a fair amount of the viewership of Drag Race given it’s large drag community and the fact that American cable channels like Logo are available on the island. And yet, most Puerto Rican queens face the same struggle each season. They often wash out of acting or comedy challenges because of their accents. It’s just disappointing for them to get on the show yet face an inevitable failure. After all, Latrice Royale was never clocked by the judges for not being able to fit into a size 2 later in the season. Why should these queens be critiqued for an accent they had when they were cast?
6.) Cynthia Lee Fontaine is not Cuckoo.
It’s disappointing that the Puerto Rican queens are often viewed as zany or over the top. They are trying to be as savvy as American queens by bringing their own tag lines, sound bytes and memorable moments to the show. But they have different cultural touch points. The few gay characters in Spanish-speaking television shows and novellas are often over the top. Some Drag icons to Puerto Rican queens are stars like Charytin, La Lupe, Charo or the metaphysical Liberace himself Walter Mercado. By their standard, Cynthia is an understated wallflower. So her run in the “RuCo’s Empire” challenge was not insane but what the maxi challenge required, over-the-top acting. But over-the-top to Cynthia was obviously more than anyone bargained for. Either way, she and her Cucu have found their way into everyone’s hearts and won Miss Congeniality.
7.) Does Hating Bob Make You Racist? Maybe…
Bob, like Bianca Del Rio and Raja, assassinated every challenge on the show. He was a clear frontrunner based on pure talent. An admitted fan boy, he came to the competition to win. Now there’s nothing wrong with rooting for Naomi Smalls or Kim Chi or any of your favorites. But there’s a difference between voting for someone else vs. against Bob. It’s strange to think the people he’s sought to entertain and whose rights he’s fought for would go that extra step to hate him. It’s okay to dislike someone but many strong African American competitors have been hated, and even attacked on social media with racist comments. Let’s never forget what happened to Jasmine Masters and Kennedy Davenport last season. It’s worth taking the extra step to double check that petty dislike isn’t racism with a beat mug.
8.) ShoCanTell It’s a Bad Idea
Is it offensive to have Derrick Berry impersonate Laura Bell Bundy impersonating a borderline-offensive racial stereotype? Ehhh, kinda. Shots where fired when Sierra Mannie wrote her now infamous open letter to white gay men to stop impersonating black women. Her article, while a little inflammatory, did touch on a major issue. While white gay men may identify with black women but they are privileged by not being black or female. Who doesn’t love to tongue pop and say, “Okurrr?” But we should also be mindful that the struggle is in fact real and we have an opportunity to encourage change. Rather than pretending to be ratchet or use race for play we should venerate our African American idols and avoid stereotypes.
9.) Ratchet vs. Black
There is a huge difference between ratchet and black. In the “RuCo Empire” challenge it would be easy to boil down Empire, one of the most popular all-African American ensemble series, as just a series of mouth pops and ghetto colloquialisms. But it is more than that. RuPaul was just being her media mogul stunt-queen self by referencing what is huge in pop culture. But it was a bit tough to piece together with a cast of so many Non-African American queens. Also, when Michelle Visage reduced Bob’s penchant for dance gear to ratchet drag it didn’t do any one any favors.
10.) Race Blind Cosplay
Here’s something this season that really inspired change. Whether it was Bob the Drag Queen as Carol Channing or Thorgy Thor as Michael Jackson they showed that you can celebrate a star even if they are not your race. And you can do so without changing your color cosmetically. Also, a special shout out to Dax ExclamationPoint who donned Emma Frost and Sailor Mars cosplay at RuPaul’s Drag Con.
RuPaul’s Drag Race is too busy being an amazing television series. It doesn’t need to be more PC or lose any of its irreverence. But as fans and victims of oppression, we need think critically, ask questions, and ensure we aren’t jumping to potentially racist conclusions or missing the bigger picture.
We also need to be sure to check racism whenever and wherever we see it.
DCguy
Oh My God, interesting topic, but 2 attempts to attack Derrik on it? Derrik wasn’t my favorite queen this season but what is up? Two of the recaps were literally 95% about not liking Derrik and now Derrik is blamed for White Privilege because he has a job.
He got the job because he looks like Brittany Spears, it’s a celeb lookalike job. And he didn’t say he had never been challenged like this before in life, he said it about his drag. I.E. because he has a job doing one thing, he hadn’t been challenged in that job to do something else.
Seriously, What is the personal baggage with Derrik? Sheesh, it’s boring.
DCguy
Interesting topic, but 2 attempts to attack Derrik on it? Derrik wasn’t my favorite queen this season but what is up? Two of the recaps were literally 95% about not liking Derrik and now He is blamed for White Privilege because he has a job.
He got the job because he looks like Brittany Spears, it’s a celeb lookalike job. And he didn’t say he had never been challenged like this before in life, he said it about his drag. I.E. because he has a job doing one thing, he hadn’t been challenged in that job to do something else.
Seriously, What is the personal baggage with Derrik? Sheesh, it gets old. You want to talk about rac-ism, you can bring up the fact that RuPaul was called Rac-ist for picking two black winners in a row seasons 1 and 2. (Then again, Season 2 was Tyra).
DCguy
Sorry, Queerty flagged the first comment, then let it through or something (Or I hit the button twice), sorry for the double!
zaneymcbanes
GREAT article! Love to see this kind of stuff on Queerty. Christian Cintron, you explained things in such a clear, accessible way, thank you!
sfprman
Kim Chi should have won but the kind of racism that is rampant and ignored – black on Asian racism – reared its head once again. Take another look at the comments on the show about Kim Chi versus this article’s complaint against white folk “acting black.”
Matt Achine
@sfprman: “Rampant and ignored – black on Asian racism.” Okay, but things that only go on in your mind don’t count. Fair enough?
DCguy
@sfprman:
Kim Chi had phenominal looks. But doesn’t present as well as Bob or Naomi in other areas. If Drag is only about an artistic aspect of it, then Kim would crush it hands down. But they also need to step up on stage and hold the audience in the palm of their hand and keep them entertained. Bob has that over Kim. As for Asian discrimination, the winner of Season 3 Raja is Asian. In fact An Asian American won Drag Race before anybody White did. So please, tell me all about How Kim Lost for being Asian.
ScaryRussianHeather
Here’s some racism for ya.
You deliberately cited Bob, Raja and Bianca as the queens who “slayed every challenge which is patently false.
While it was Jinkx Monsoon who indisputably set the record for the highest number of “slays” in Drag Race history, having eight consecutive wins/highs. More than anyone else before or after her. Bummer she’s white I guess.
Raja? please. Manila had a better record. And Kim Chi technically had a better record than Bob, having not fallen into BTM2 at all.
Xzamilio
@sfprman: Yeah, no… less we forget, Raja is Asian, and was the winner of Season 3. Furthermore, Kim Chi was protected more than Derrick Barry, even though she didn’t really need it, with her fashion and groundbreaking makeup. After seeing her on the show, she had a great aesthetic, but if she had to lip sync for her life, she would have went home against any of those girls.
@ScaryRussianHeather: Jinkx only won two main challenges during her run, Roxxy won two, and so did Alaska, and Alaska never fell in the bottom… but Jinkx won the Season 5.
Bob won THREE and lip synced once… and it’s arguable that Kim Chi didn’t lip sync during the show because she was nowhere near as performance ready as the other girls. Bob was the clear frontrunner from the start.
Alistair Wiseman
The contents of this article, is just another example of:
Liberalism is a mental disorder.
dean089
“No fats, no fems, no Asians” is pretty much standard fare in any gay setting, from bars to dating websites. We didn’t need this TV show to bring that to light. As for “You’re hot, for a black guy,” that can be heard ANYWHERE and is not exclusively an LGBT problem.
DuMaurier
Rather surprised an editor didn’t catch this one; in #5 the author reminds us (rightly) that Puerto Rico is “part of the United States”, then in # we’re told that Puerto Ricans “are trying to be as savvy as AMERICAN queens” (caps mine)
judysdad
I laugh that anyone would even offer up an analysis of this kind of dated shit. Come on…drag queens? Gay men are really still into this stuff? Unreal.
gemininature
@judysdad: You must have been living under a rock, this show has been one of the most successful gay TV shows for the last 9 years. It’s THE single most successful show on the gay channel Logo. Gay men, straight women, LOTS of people LOVE the show and it has revitalized the interest in drag as an artistic medium. Yes, gay men are REALLY still into this, and so is an increasing mainstream audience. So right now, I’m laughing at your ignorance.
gemininature
@DuMaurier: But you know what they meant though….”mainland” queens
DuMaurier
@gemininature: Of course I know what they “meant”. I still say I think it would have been a good idea to find another way to say it, especially (but not only) in the context of the article’s central message.
He BGB
Not alot of racism from what I have seen
Shadeaux
I really can’t get with the Kim Chi thing. She didn’t do shit! NOTHING AT ALL but paint and stand there. She couldn’t walk, she was “talk challenged”, she couldn’t dance, she couldn’t even lie down without falling. Her last lip sync in the finale was her walking from side to side. It was RuPaul’s DRAG RACE where you’re suppose to serve female realness and be an entertainer. She was painting characters on her face. She shouldn’t have even been in the finale. She couldn’t even stand up so do you really think she could handle ChiChi in a lip sync battle the way ChiChi served in EVERY battle she was in? Please.
Lindoro Almaviva
OK, I have to say something or I am going to explode:
1. Really queen? If there is a reason why I am glad the season is over is because i am not going to have to come here and correctly predict that the recaps are going to be mostly about how much you dislike Derrick. Shit, girl, five Gs.
2. Interesting that Derrick gets shit on for not gluing her browns down when Darienne Lake and Courtney Act did the same thing for most of their participation in the show.
3. Thank you for your kind words about Puerto Rico and the struggles the island and the LGBT Community faces every day. That being said, let’s not forget that Nina Flowers went all the way to the top with less English skills than people like April Carrion. Not to shit on my Boricua brothers and sisters but our education system dictates English classes every day from 1st to 12th grade. I understand the accent (I have one), but I have less patience than most for bad grammar and excuses because by the time they get out of highschool, most Puerto Ricans have had hundreds of hours of English Instruction. Sorry, but I learned my English from the same teachers that taught 98% of my classmates; who still can not speak English. It is not as if I grew up priviledged and had a private education with English immersion.
DCguy
@Alistair Wiseman:
The fact that you can’t avoid talking about how much you hate liberals no matter what the article is about shows a derangement syndrome that is frankly weird.
I get it, you want to be different, you want mommy and daddy to like you and to think you aren’t one of “THOSE” gays. But the fact is, getting foaming at the mouth crazy in support of a political group that thinks you shouldn’t have the right to work, to function as a full member of society etc… shows a level of self hatred that is beyond crazy.
n900mixalot
This is the best article I’ve ever read on this site.
David Aventura
@sfprman: “black on Asian racism – reared its head once again.” Really, dude? You were clearly traumatized by something in your past and have not gotten over it. Reach out to the Black people that hurt you. Tell them how you feel. They probably won’t even remember you, though you think of them often. It’s funny because it’s true.
Capone78
Not sure I agree with this article – in fact I don’t. At all.
Racism is a vile thing, but attributing it to all things you don’t like is counterproductive.
While gayville is clearly a very competitive town, I believe that confusing preference with bias is wrong. Men in general, and possibly gay men specifically are oriented towards external stimulants. That means that men (sexually) tend to be turned on by features such as body, face etc.
It’s also a fact that people are usually attracted to features that mimic their own (hence why hetero boys are said to look for their mother in their bride-to-be). This translates into caucasian guys having a preference for other caucasian guys. That’s not racism. That’s preference.
Capone78
@Shadeaux: Agree that Kim Chi was a bit onesided. Being able to do proper makeup (or “beat your mug”) is part of being a drag queen, and I believe that Kim Chi is OUTSTANDING in that aspect.
But becoming the next Drag Queen requires versatility. Bob had that. She wasn’t great in all aspects (some, like me, find her a bit egocentric and I personally don’t find her as funny as previous comedy queens like Jinkx Monsoon or Bianca DelRio). But Bob was (fairly) good at EVERYTHING, and that’s what makes you a star. Naomi was flawless, her outfits were gorgeous (and probably more fashion sense than Bob), but when you put all things together, she fell short.
Leo1128
@DCguy: Raja is half Dutch. That means she’s as white as she’s Asian. Saying that raja represents the Asian community is just as ridiculous as saying that someone from Puerto Rico who’s half Spanish represents the entire white community just because she’s half spanish. And also, maybe you didn’t know but East Asians and south Asians are just as different as, for example, Swedish people and Spanish people are. They have completely different culture, and they look NOTHING alike from an Asian’s perspective. And as for the discrimination thing, the thing is that raja doesn’t really look “Asian” as in the stereotypical Asian man that you’d imagine. And don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying that just because she’s half Dutch half Indonesian she can’t identify herself as Asian. What I’m saying is that there’s definitely certain kind of racism/discrimination that you only have to face when you “LOOK” that particular race. It’s just like black people with darker skin tend to experience more racism/discrimination than black people with lighter skin do.
Kimchi’s pure East Asian, actually FROM East Asia, and actually look “Asian” as in the stereotypical nerdy-looking slanted-eyed kinda Asian guy, and has an Asian accent, and has a style of drag that could be described as “Japanime-inspired” which Americans struggle to appeeciate. That’s why she lost. It’s plain and simple.