Amish-taken Opportunity

Amish Pastor Convicted Of Aiding In Abduction of Former Lesbian Couple’s Child

Kenneth L. Miller, a Beachy Amish-Mennonite pastor from Stuarts, VA, was convicted yesterday by a federal jury in Burlington , VT for aiding and abetting the flight of Lisa A. Miller and her daughter Isabelle Miller-Jenkins in 2009, to avoid court-ordered visits from Miller’s former civil union partner, Janet Jenkins. 

Lisa Miller and Janet Jenkins broke up in 2003, at which point Miller moved to Virginia and declared herself a born-again Christian, the New York Times reports. Miller tried in vain to strip Jenkins of her parental rights and interfered with court-mandated visits, leading a federal judge to threaten to transfer custody of Isabella to Jenkins in 2009.

Here, Pastor Miller — no relation to Lisa Miller — intervened. Homosexuality being a sin in the eyes of Beachy Amish-Menonites, the pastor helped transport Ms. Miller and Isabella from Canada to Nicaragua, where they obtained shelter as missionaries and where federal agents believe they are still in hiding.

The pastor’s lawyer tried to contend that Mr. Miller did not know he was violating court orders by assisting in the absconding of Lisa Miller, however prosecutors proved that he made efforts to hide his actions, such as stipulating that the flight from Canada to Nicaragua would not touch down in America.

A fellow pastor in Canada who had refused to transport Miller and her daughter across the Canadian-US border because he thought he would be breaking the law further helped to undermine Mr. Miller’s case.

Kenneth Miller could face up to three years in prison but for now he simply had to fork over his passport. The pastor might appeal his case, however, arguing that the trial should have taken place in Virginia where Mr. Miller’s shady dealings took place.

Get Queerty Daily

Subscribe to Queerty for a daily dose of #amish #born-againchristians #janetjenkins stories and more


  • The Real Mike in Asheville

    Delighted for the conviction; disappointed that the sentence is not for as long as the child is being denied the right to be with her legally recognized mother. I’d lock the asshole up until the child is returned to Janet Jenkins.

  • Cam

    Throw him in jail, and find the other mother in central America and throw her in jail as well.

  • Dean Lowry

    When I read the title, I thought it was a Sean Connery reference: Mishtaken Opportunity. Clevah guhl, Pushy.

    xoxo Dean

  • charli girl

    Im so so proud od the state of Vt judicial system!

  • Stay Calm and Carry On

    Glad he was convicted, but for the sake of accuracy, it should read “Mennonite” rather than Amish.

  • mike ramon

    I thought those mennonite’s were supposed to be a peaceful, non-violent, mind-my-own- business, type of people. You never know.

  • Jack

    @mike ramon: Crazy people are found everywhere. Let’s just hope they’ll get the bastard before he causes more ruckus.

Comments are closed.