
Move over, Ellen. TV has a new mean girl and her name is Dr. Phil McGraw.
As conversations about toxic work environments in the entertainment world continue, a host of employees have alleged “fear, intimidation, and racism” on the set of one of TV’s most popular talk shows: Dr. Phil.
A new report by Buzzfeed documents the testimony of a dozen current and former employees on the show that allege an abusive workplace environment. All spoke to the outlet on the condition of anonymity.
“Everyone was just pretty miserable. You would walk into the building and there was just a palpable dread and anxiety,” one former employee says. “Dr. Phil — the show about mental health where everybody who works on it has terrible mental health because our work conditions were really bad.”
McGraw rose to the status of a household name in the 1990s thanks to his frequent appearances on The Oprah Winfrey Show. McGraw’s popularity with viewers led him to get his own talk show spinoff in 2002. It is currently in its 20th season. In that time, he has also come under scrutiny for his ethics and advice. Though he does hold a doctorate in clinical psychology, he is not currently licensed.
“I would have nightmares. I would literally be working in my sleep and have nightmares about something being wrong or not turning in something the right way,” another employee adds. “Even when I quit, I had to go to therapy for it, which is crazy because you’re working for a therapist.”
Related: Dr. Phil’s show yesterday was a transphobic trainwreck and we don’t even know where to begin
In the report, other former staffers also allege that the producers of the show consciously promote racist stereotypes, and manipulate show guests in dangerous ways.
In one disturbing anecdote, a former employee claims he was told to make sure a guest didn’t take her prescribed medication.
“We were specifically instructed, ‘Make sure that she doesn’t take her medication before she goes onstage,’ because they wanted her to look unstable and quote-unquote, ‘crazy,’ for lack of a better term,” the employee recalls.
“She did take the medication because no one got there in time and I remember thinking, ‘My God, I don’t want to be the one to tell them or dissuade them from that.’ And that’s all for the sake of TV. Obviously, this girl should be on her medication and that’s what we’re trying to get her help for, but for the sake of TV they wanted her to look off the rails.”
Though the staff members interviewed by BuzzFeed allege McGraw knew of the abusive behavior on his set, they also allege the biggest culprit in creating the toxic environment was executive producer Carla Pennington.
Witnesses in the report describe Pennington’s verbal tirades, calling “idiots,” “stupid,” and “retards.” They also claim she threatened to fire staffers on a regular basis, and even bragged about who she got to quit the show. Others allege that she would mock guests.
“It was traumatizing. It was the worst hour of your life,” a former employee says of Pennington’s rants. “There was full-blown yelling, calling people idiots, and slamming doors, and it would not be acceptable in any other job in any other business. Then after, everybody’s upset and everybody’s crying.”
“She reprimanded me so severely that I couldn’t breathe,” another former employee adds. “It has nothing to do with my performance and everything to do with whether or not they liked you. They would look me dead in the eye and go, ‘Do you even know what day it is? Do you even know? Are you that stupid?’”
Lawyers for McGraw and Pennington, as well as a Dr. Phil spokesperson, have all denied the report. A publicist for the show referred to the reporting as a “click-bait story.”
Pennington’s attorney, Bryan J. Freedman, called the report “a work of fiction,” while McGraw’s lawyer H. Patrick Morris said McGraw “categorically denies” the allegations. Still, this isn’t the first time Dr. Phil and its titular host have come under fire for allegations of employee abuse.
In 2016, a former employee alleged McGraw locked her and several other staffers in a room and verbally berated them over leaks to the press. That same year, former guests on the show alleged they were given access to alcohol and drugs before filming. Producers for the show denied both reports.
In the meantime, as the story continues to develop, viewers and readers of the BuzzFeed report have begun to share their thoughts on Twitter…
I ? Believe The Employees??
Current And Former “Dr. Phil” Employees Say The Set Is A Toxic Workplace. – BuzzFeed News https://t.co/PmyzRbBnLw
— Kiersten (@1stKiersten) February 10, 2022
There are some notable parallels between our reporting and @BuzzFeed's recent story on the workplace at Dr. Phil, including discriminatory treatment against Black guests and a requirement that employees submit photos of guests' teeth prior to taping. https://t.co/pPteS7w3ON
— Nicole Einbinder (@NicoleEinbinder) February 10, 2022
I really want to see @BuzzFeed
stupid articles with @DrPhil employees and their insane stories , the funniest thing is Even the problem about him all the stupid Tabloids added Ellen’s name to their articles to sell their shits (3/4 )— Jane_Roberts (@jane101roberts) February 11, 2022
@PreserenKelly we also know he gets his mail in his underwear
— Meghan Maureen (@Keggs719) February 11, 2022
i’m shocked said no one
— Hey, Daddy, I want an Oompa Loompa. (@bbguyla) February 11, 2022
Jim
Phil was never about mental health. You don’t do therapy in front of a crowd.
And Oprah goes to the bank
johncp56
I have to believe the past employees, he is a Bully right on the screen, daily and the filters on his wife and her fake creams is a joke, southern white trash lol ? no?
Mr. Stadnick
Oprah and her cadre have always been hacks and charlatans in my book. Dr Phil and Dr Oz should be ashamed and Oprah should be as well. Bad medicine and bad TV.
dario717
I agree with you, and I am unanimous in that.
CNY1983
Oprah, Oz and Mcgraw – colossal waste of time.
Cam
Same B.S. denials they tried at Ellen at first. If there are MULTIPLE employees talking, I’m going to believe them over Dr. Phil.
And what a shock, a guy with his accent turns out to be racist.
Hey, Thanks Oprah, for elevating him, Dr. OZ, and Jenny McCarthy.
andrewl
While not condoning toxic work culture in any way shape or form, it must not be tolerated, I have to ask why didn’t people tell the aggressive management do not ever treat me like this, yell back and/or quit. Are people in the US that concerned about their jobs.? I wouldn’t put up with it and would walk. When it all boils down to it, you have control over the environment that you put yourself in, don’t be afraid to take action.
Jack Meoff
Not sure which country you are from but I was thinking the same thing.
Cam
Because in Hollywood they would have badmouthed them. If they quit the Doctor Phil Show, chances are the other shows that filmed at the same studio, were produced by the same company etc. wouldn’t hire them. They could be blackballed from a huge number of other jobs. They only way out would be to quietly look for another job, take it and then quit.
Problem is, there are so many connecting ties in the industry that if they were looking, somebody they interviewed with could call the Dr. Phill show and let them know that somebody from their show was looking.
Workers have zero protections in the States.
BaltoSteve
It was in the write up. There are folks who did quit. And the executive producer, Carla Pennington, would brag about making them quit.
cteelphoto
Dr Phil was one of the speakers at one of those “Tony Robbins” style business conferences where D-list celebrities are hired to give b/s motivational speeches. There were microphone issues during his portion of the event, distracting him (really not noticeable to the audience) and he stopped and berated the technicians around him, basically implying they were stupid and didn’t know how to do their jobs. This went on for a good 15 minutes or so and I think he thought he was being funny. He lost the audience, and never recovered. What an A-hole.
Terrycloth
Dr..( I use that term very loosely) Phil’s show is the Jerry springer show of physco analysis. It’s basically a platform for his wife’s surgically enhanced face can hawk her face and anti aging serums. The topics of discussion are so embellished and over the top all for ratings .he should have been canceled a long time ago..
Rikki Roze
The dr. Phil show is so popular because such a broad section of Americans totally relate to it. Says something about how “great” America is.
scotty
i wonder how that’s working out for him?