Christian: Darryl Stephens; Andy: Chris Colfer
Oddly enough, Chris Colfer is kind of the perfect Andy on paper. His character in the film, Struck By Lightning, embodies Andy’s main personalities traits – stubborn, studious, kind-hearted and virginal. What’s hard to imagine is him ever submitting himself to BDSM but maybe, just maybe, for Darryl Stephens he might. Not only is Stephens handsome but he has secret grin that makes you wonder if he’s hiding something.
Sagarika
Maher and Colton… no. I cannot see Maher as Grey anymore than Colton as Andy. But… if the casting is reversed…
My choices would be Zach Quinto and Chris or Adam Ruggerio.
Dev.C
OMG these choices are so hard, I can’t decide.
The thought of Zachary Quinto and Ezra Miller is beyond hot and Wentworth Miller and Adamo Ruggerio I’m speechless because I didn’t even know I wanted to see them together. Amazing list!
Niall
LOL, most of the actors listed though are more likely to balk at such a role. Gay actors already have their career threatened enough just by being gay(unfortunately), they don’t need to sabotage it more by starring in such rubbish.