Christian: Sean Maher; Andy: Colton Haynes
Sean Maher may not initially come to mind as the Christian Grey type but after playing Don John in Joss Whedon’s Much Ado About Nothing, it’s hard not to consider him. Maher can easily play a manipulator as well as a seducer. Haynes may be an odd choice for Andy but it’s one that could be a lot of fun to play with considering his domineering, popular character on Teen Wolf. Besides the pairing looks good together.