Christian: Wentworth Miller; Andy: Adamo Ruggiero
Having most prominently played a prisoner, we know Wentworth Miller could handle the darker sides of Grey’s character. The actor has also been out of the limelight long enough to create a mysterious air around him. Meanwhile, Adamo Ruggiergo has the youthful appeal that fits Andy’s college age character. On Degrassi, the actor dealt with the conflicts of coming out and that’s the perfect predecessor for a character unsure how to deal with such a sexually confident pursuer. Does he relent himself to Grey/Miller or not? It’s a choice that could lead to unintended consequences.
But honestly, who would you cast in a gay version of the film?