Jail Bait Idol Edition!

Gay Blind Item Madness!!

There are just too many possible answers for this blind item! There are, after all, so many potentially gay American Idol stars: “Which teenage “American Idol” reject is already cropping up on the L.A. gay bar scene?”

Obviously it’s not Sanjaya – he already made clear he’s no queer. Blake Lewis also claims to be 100% lady-loving. In fact, he’s voracious about it: “I’m definitely not gay. No. I’m straight. I’ll scream it out loud.”

Ah, that really brings us back…