Hot To Horrifying: 15 Guys Share Their First Gay Hookup Stories

There’s really nothing like that very first time, when awkward fumbling and nervous excitement begets either ecstatic pleasure or embarrassing failure. Luckily, most of us get lots of chances to try, try again.

For better or for worse, everyone remembers their first time.

Here to take you back to those formative years are fifteen Whispers about that first time hooking up with a guy.


I'm ashamed to admit my first gay experience was at a gas station glory hole

My boyfriend and I had sex for the first time. I'm still not sure how I feel about it, I wish I was more excited

I was so nervous the first time I had sex with another guy I threw up

The first time I had sex was in my parent's basement while watching Star Wars. My parents don't know that I've had sex or that I'm gay.

First time I went to a gay club I lost my VIRGINITY

I had my first gay experience with another guy. It blew my mind... as well as some other things.

I had gay sex for the first time with a guy about 17 years older than me and he was a school superintendent.

I'm gay and I tried having sex for the first time but I couldn't get it in... so embarrassing. I thought it would be easier

The first time I had gay sex was with my high school's star quarterback

He finally talked me into letting him go down on me and it was damn good. First time getting that from another guy.

 I had my first gay experience today at the gym... I guess the black guy stereotype is true considering I can't walk ????

Went to a gay bar with a gay friend of mine. Bartender got me wasted and I ended up having sex with a guy for the first time. I have a girlfriend...

I'm a 22 year old gay guy. I recently had sex for the first time and now I just want sex like almost all the time. It's crazy.

My first gay experience would've been better if the guy had a lot more down there ????????

I had gay sex for the first time today. It was amazing, I love every inch of his body and I think I really like him now. I feel special when he kisses me.

For more confidential stories, check out Whisper.