Morris Richard McConnell, a 59-year-old Canadian Navy veteran, will serve a life sentence (with no eligibility for parole for 10 years) after pleading guilty to second-degree murder after slaying Kelvin John Osborne, 42, in March 2008 by stabbing him in the face, head, and neck, and beating him in the head with a hammer with at least nine bludgeoning blows. McConnell — who told police he had confusion about his sexuality, but was not gay — maintains it was in self-defense, because Osborne, an openly gay man who sometimes went by “Rose,” “danced in front of McConnell and requested oral sex,” and ew, scary fags. The men, who knew each other previously, walked to McConnell’s home hand-in-hand after leaving an inn, according to witnesses. And while McConnell initially told police “He’s dead, I killed him … When he asked me to make love to him I hit him about 100 times with a hammer and slit his throat with a butcher knife,” he later said he had almost no recollection of the attack. Oh, I didn’t yet mention: prosecutors opted not to charge McConnell with a hate crime.
Scott Cooper, representing the Canadian government (or rather, “the Crown”), told the court “this was not a hate crime. … His own [sexual] orientation issues may have put him in a position where this event occurred. … This was an act that was committed as a result of self-loathing.”
You see, because McConnell hated his own sexuality so much, that he attacked a gay man shouldn’t be of consequence. Uh.
Apparently not at issue, then, is that he attacked a gay man because the man was gay, and evidently instigated, or whatever, this self-loathing.
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
Tip for straight male murderers next time you’re accused of killing a woman: Just say you were so disgusted with your heterosexual feelings that you had no choice but to make her head explode.
That’s not the only tragedy in the Osborne family:
He was the younger brother of Helen Betty Osborne, a 19-year-old woman who was kidnapped off the street in The Pas in 1971. She was then raped and stabbed more than 50 times before her body was dumped in the bush outside the northern Manitoba city. Four white men were finally charged with her killing in 1987, but only one was convicted. Dwayne Archie Johnston was found guilty of second-degree murder and given a life sentence with no chance of parole for 10 years, which he successfully applied for.
Jack
The photo you’ve used to illustrate this article is in utterly poor taste, Queerty. This isn’t some trashy Morning Goods feature. Someone was killed.
prohomo
@Jack: I agree…exactly my thought.
What a horrible tragedy for John Osborne and his sister.
Hyhybt
@Jack: You think THAT would make a good Morning Goods?
Jack
@Hyhybt: No… although it might be an improvement, some days…
My point was that it’s fine for certain articles/features not treated seriously – for example, Morning Goods – but some SHOULD be taken seriously. Using that picture to illustrate an article about someone being murdered is in poor taste.
Daez
This just further illustrates a problem with hate crimes laws in general. Hate crimes laws are ridiculous. If the punishment isn’t harsh enough to fit the crime then change the punishment in regards to all cases not just a select few. Instead of arguing over rather this case should have applied to the hate crimes law, we should be arguing over rather 10 years till parole is a strong enough penalty for murder.
Hamburglar
@Daez: If there were no hate crimes laws, and never had been, would you then be against all other considerations of motive in deciding punishment? Because that’s really all it is.
Saffer
What always astounds me is, why the fuck don’t you just fight back??? I’m a gay guy and I’ve beaten the crap out of one or two straight dudes in my time who gave me shit about being a faggot (OK being a 6″0 and 250 pound bear helps a bit…) Do some basic martial arts training; the principles are really easy: go for the soft bits, i.e. grab he bassssturrrdd by the nuts and twist as hard as you can, kick to the face/nose, gouge the eyes, bite, punch to the solar plexus – stop being fucking victims! Maybe you should come live in South Africa for a while so we can teach you to look after yourselves…
prohomo
@Saffer: Finally, a sane answer to all this bullying:The best advice: fight back.