Thomas Beatie’s story continues to pack a punch. In fact today’s NY Times piece on the pregnant trans man provides two in one!
First the smaller item: publishing house St. Martin’s Press has shelved Beatie’s planned memoir. Perhaps because of speculation that Beatie was in it for the money?
Regardless of Beatie’s shrinking spotlight and gossip fodder, there’s a bigger and far more important cultural narrative at work. And one that’s almost as American as apple pie…
“When there’s a lot of fascination around a figure like Thomas Beatie,” said Judith Halberstam, a professor of English and gender studies at the University of Southern California, “it points to other changes already happening elsewhere in the culture.”
Among the changes Ms. Halberstam noted are medical innovations that have expanded the possibilities for body modification. There are also studies that indicate, as Ms. Halberstam noted, that women respond sexually to the individual, before differentiating by sex. And the broadening legal scope of marriage has also had its effects on people like Mr. Beatie, who says of himself, “I am transgender, legally male, and legally married to Nancy,” but who might have trouble holding on to some of those assertions if he did something as simple as moving from Oregon.
Americans, Ms. Halberstam said, have long been fascinated by narratives of sexual transformation, at least since the era of Christine Jorgensen, an early male-to-female transsexual (born George Jorgensen Jr. in the Bronx) whose sex change, performed by doctors in Sweden, prompted The Daily News to run a front page story under the headline “Ex-GI Becomes Blonde Beauty” and made Miss Jorgensen as tabloid-notorious then as Mr. Beatie is, the man who “went abroad and came back a broad.”
The Jorgensen case in 1951 was treated as groundbreaking, just as Mr. Beatie’s was on “Oprah,” despite the well-established fact that physicians at the German Institute of Sexual Science had performed successful sexual reassignment surgeries decades before. If Miss Jorgensen’s story prefigured Mr. Beatie’s, it also pointed toward a future in which gender continues to change in response to changing laws and mores and, as important, new technology.
Are we the only ones envisioning Trouble On Triton, author Sam Delany’s “heterotopia” in which there are about a dozen different genders? And space ships? It’s awesome. You should read it.
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
rick
this is NOT, i repeat NOT, a transgendered man.
this is a lesbian that had her breasts removed.
if you have all the functioning female parts, you are FEMALE!
Tom
Agree with Rick. Plus she’s clearly just in it for the money and attention. I feel bad for her kid.
RPCV
S/He is, excuse my language, fucked up………
yaksha2
not this again, commentors. let thomas beatie and the law decide what thomas beatie is. and let’s hope the law is more understanding than you.
Hazumu Osaragi
Hi;
May I interject a real life situation. I’d like to hear your guidance on this.
My mother was given a drug to take to lessen the chance of miscarriage and promote healthy babies — that’s what the doctor told her. The drug is Diethylstilbestrol, or DES. In male fetuses, it feminizes the brains of one in five of us ‘DES sons’.
I finally came to terms with this, and realized my choice was transition or die. So, I’m now a male-to-female transsexual who’s had ‘the operation.’ I’ve changed all my legal paperwork and although I still have a male body with XY chromosomes, it has been retrofitted to approximate female anatomy, which is good because if I ever end up in an accident, there will be no ’surprise’ for the first responders.
I ‘pass’ very well, thank you. Only rarely do strangers figure out I was not born this way. Most people have to be told, by me, or, more often, by someone else who just has to ‘drop the bomb.’
So my question to you is — knowing what you know now about me, and assuming for the moment you get absolute power to make the determination — which restroom and changing facility do you feel I, a male-to-female transsexual, should use when in public spaces? What gender am I?
I eagerly await your responses;
Hazumu Osaragi
Progression
I’m in favor of transitioned people coming out. No transition is 100%. Have the pride to proclaim oneself transitioned male or transitioned female. The more trangendered people come out, the fewer “bombs” there will be to drop (and the less shocking the blast will be). Concealment is the real danger, the true threat to acceptance and safety.
Amber LeMay
No. 5 – Hazumu
You answered your own question with “So, I’m now a male-to-female transsexual who’s had ‘the operation.” Beatie can’t say that. If the headlines would read “Trans Man Has Baby” I could accept that… but she ain’t a man until she’s had the adadictomy. For more of my comments… http://houseoflemay.blog-city.com/dear_amber__can_men_get_pregnant.htm
Miss Understood
What’s with all the anger? Why the hell should you care if he identifies as male and has a baby? You sound like the right wing nuts railing against gay marriage. It’s his personal decision and does not affect you. If you want your personal freedom you should respect others.
lighthouse
I agree with rick’s comment and pay attention
to his statement. Rick give you clearly and be
acceptance.. Move on…
Neil
Blech, gross to see transphobic comments here on a queer blog.