The letter, published in The Times’ Thursday edition, opines the piece was “disdainfully” written and that it reinforced “the stereotype about gay men as hysterics.”
The profile, headlined “The Tear-Stained Confessions of Sam Smith,” includes paragraphs of purple prose like this:
He cried when he talked about the house he grew up in; when he reminisced about a crush who turned on him; when he talked about his first voice teacher. He cried when he talked about writing “Pray,” a song from his new album, “The Thrill of It All.” He cried when he talked about the children he met in Mosul, Iraq, on a recent humanitarian mission, and then he looked down at the sparrow tattoo he got on his arm when he returned home, with “Be good, be kind” written in Arabic beneath it, and he cried again. He cried talking about how much he cried when he watched the movie “Inside Out.” And he cried when he talked about love. When he talked about love, he leaned back on the couch with his limbs splayed and looked upward as if he died momentarily just considering a concept so big.
This is followed by even more melodrama in the next graph, which goes a little something like this:
Yes, the floodgates really opened once Mr. Smith began to talk about love — big, delicious tears that coated and magnified his sad, glorious blue eyeballs but never quite leaked out onto his cheeks.
Cunningham was highly displeased with the not-so subtle satire, writing:
“I can’t help wondering if there’s any connection between Mr. Smith’s sexuality and the implication that what’s most important for readers to know about him is that he cries a lot.”
Later, he says:
“It strikes me as unfortunate not only that the story’s first paragraphs perpetuate a certain stereotype about gay men as hysterics, but also that Mr. Smith, who is so candid about his experience of being shamed for his openness about his sexuality, finds himself shamed by his interviewer as well.”
Do you think there’s something subliminally homophobic about the profile, or is Michael Cunningham upset over nothing? Sound off in the comments below.