I think what makes someone get away with a joke that rides that line is the spirit of the joke, who the joke is really about, and mostly, the heart of what transcends beyond the words. If some frat boy says a joke about a race or sexual identity that is not his own it’s going to be received differently than someone who’s heart and position is clearly on—let’s say—the right side of history.
But comedy isn’t timeless. It has to change with the times. There’s stuff in my old special Jesus is Magic that makes me cringe in the context of today, that doesn’t say the same things or would have a different inference in this time of our current epidemic of white cops killing black teenagers, for instance. You know? That’s what makes it art, dare I say. Simply that, what it is and what it means depends on whose eyes it’s being seen through, in the context of their experience and the context of the time in history it’s being seen.”
— Sarah Silverman in an interview with AfterEllen to promote her May 16 appearance at An Evening with Women, a benefit for the Los Angeles LGBT Center
Kieran
You just know this privileged, talentless c u n t really believes her sh!t don’t stink. Not impressed.
petensfo
I remember Silverman doing a bit about having been touched inappropriately by her male gynecologist. “I was so conflicted as a Jewish girl, because after all, he was a doctor.”
That, is walkin’ a line. Love her. 🙂
Clark35
@Kieran: Very true.
Glücklich
Maybe I don’t watch enough comedians but to me, if it’s in a comedy act, it’s not malicious. I love those risqué “Ooooooooohhh” jokes about race, gender, etc. Daniel Tosh and Sarah Silverman put in their acts, or the jokes on those Comedy Central roasts.
For readers in San Francisco, where I’m from though currently living in NYC, you KNOW how tiresome all those people who get offended by EVERYTHING can be.
jar
Her offensiveness comes purely from not being funny.
jason smeds
Is AfterEllen even owned by gay women? I suspect it might be one of these corporate entities that is owned by straight guys. Lesbian web-sites are, by and large, a joke.