Now that she has been officially sanctified by Pope Francis (even if the Vatican is now futilely distancing itself from Davis) as religious liberty incarnate, Kim Davis will be hailed far and wide as the conscience of a godless nation. In fact, she is already being compared to Mahatma Gandhi, who made civil disobedience a global philosophy in his fight for Indian independence.
It’s pretty rich to hear someone like Pat Buchanan evoke Gandhi in relation to Davis, when Buchanan had nothing but unkind words for Gandhi when the movie of the same name was released in the 1980s.
Of course, philosophical consistency is not what you expect from the right-wing. They’ll use whatever they can lay their hands on to make the argument. But in this case, the comparison is spectacularly off-base. By any standard, Kim Davis is no Gandhi.
Here are seven (of many) reasons how Gandhi had it all over the Kentucky clerk.
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
1 Gandhi wanted to win hearts and minds.
Gandhi had a fundamental belief in the goodness of humanity. He believed that by his example he would convince his oppressors of the worthiness of his cause. Davis isn’t interested in winning people over. She’s interested in making a statement, which is an entirely different proposition. She doesn’t want to engage those who disagree with her. She wants to show them that she’s righteous and they’re not. Her only audience is the religious right, whereas Gandhi wanted to convince an entire empire.
2 Gandhi respected everyone’s rights.
One of Gandhi’s greatest achievements was creating a movement that was meant to unify a nation of disparate peoples. In his world, the humanity of Muslims and Hindus were equal. He was far ahead of his time in respecting the rights of women. Moreover, he extended his belief to the lowest members of society, the untouchables, flying in the face of some religious leaders. It’s hard to construct a sentence that includes the words “respect,” “rights” and “Kim Davis,” who is limiting the freedom of others rather than liberating them.
3 Gandhi was an outsider.
Gandhi was deeply involved in politics, but he was not a representative of the state that he was pressuring for change. This is a key difference with Davis, whose actions require her to representative of the state. In essence, she is the law. That’s hardly a position of purity. Refusing to carry out the law when you are a government official isn’t civil disobedience. Refusing to bow to it as a citizen is.
4 Gandhi accepted his imprisonments.
Gandhi saw the punishments he received at the hands of the ruling British as an important tool in forcing change. In fact, he readily admitted he broke the law. In 1922, he actually told a sentencing judge, “The only course open to you, Mr. Judge, is…either to resign from your post or inflict on me the severest penalty.” Contrast that with Davis who wants to be honored for breaking the law but not be held accountable for it. (Davis also immediately went back on her word once she was released from prison.) You’ll also note that Gandhi believed that if you can’t carry out the law, you should resign your post. Say no more on that count.
5 Gandhi took a vow of poverty.
Gandhi’s philosophy was one of non-possession. Davis, meanwhile, has a death grip on her $80,000 a year job, to say nothing of the nepotism she’s exercised in her office by hiring her son. Of course, she learned that at her mother’s knee, since it was her mother who hired her and paid her more than the chief deputy sheriff of Rowan County.
6 Gandhi exercised decades of self-discipline.
Gandhi famously renounced sexual relations in more than forty years before his death as part of his commitment to self-restraint. (He was also a vegetarian). Davis’s self-restraint is comparatively short lived, based on her conversion just four years ago. Before that, self-restraint would hardly be the phrase to apply to her, having had three previous marriages, as well as becoming pregnant by her future third husband while still married to her first.
7 Gandhi had better hair.
That is, he had none.
Delion Bastia
Stop mentioning and publishing articles about the fucking Christian whore! Are you kidding us Queerty?
Rick Holtz
KYm is a hypocritical hillbilly bitch and the Roman Catholic puppet who gave her a private audience should die of shame. Solve the rampant pedophilia in your own house before causing an uproar in another country, Frankie. Two HUGE douchebags.
William Russell
Enough! If you stop talking about this whore, she will go back to her 4th husband and bastard children.
Kenneth L. Kish
You mean skankdefied.
Gus Haas
The intolerance of the intolerant amazes me
Giancarlo85
@Gus Haas: You don’t seem to be too bright. why should we tolerate discrimination? This is the problem with right wing trolls.
And enough of this criminal hypocrite who refuses to do her job!
Arcamenel
Gandhi also disliked black people and often referred to them as the Indian version of the n word. Google it.
Tammie Edgerton
Kim Davis, the true meaning of a fake christian.
Kangol
First, Gandhi did not act to oppress others. Kim Davis, the Pope, and others are doing so.
Second, Gandhi was not a member of the white self-described Christian majority in South Africa, where he first began advocating for peace, and Kim Davis is a white Christian woman who has every freedom but wants to take it away from others. When Gandhi returned to India, where he was a member of the Hindu majority, he advocated for people of all religions, castes, you name it. He wasn’t trying to take away equality but increase it.
White self-described “Christian” hom0phobe Kim Davis is actively aiming to oppress other people, including fellow Christians, and has a majority of the Republican Party’s voters and its presidential candidates supporting.
Tony Chaplinski
she’s barely a human being let along Mahatma Gandhi
Desert Boy
Kim ‘Misery’ Davis is a radical, rightwing, religious bigot. She’s no Gandhi. She’s more of an Anita Bryant.
aliengod
@Gus Haas: I agree. We’ve (LGB) become the most intolerant people on the planet. It’s shameful.
And come on Queerty, “officially sanctified by Pope Francis”? Talk about irresponsible journalism. Do you really have to resort to making things up for clicks? You’ve stooped to a new low. Enough with Kim Davis!
Giancarlo85
@aliengod: Oh bullshit. The most intolerant people on the planet? Why don’t you go to a republican national convention? You’ll see some of the most hypocritical intolerant people in the world, up there with ISIL. And what is “LGB”? Again with that made-up acronym.
Enough with you!
aliengod
@Giancarlo85: Shh! Go away little one. The adults are talking.
Giancarlo85
@aliengod: That excludes you, little runt. You are not an adult. You are not capable of a rational discussion. And you scream about how intolerant the gays are lol… when you’re the fool who votes republican and supports republicans.
aliengod
@Giancarlo85: Oh little Giancarlo. Did mommy spare the rod and spoil the child? You’re so feisty.
Giancarlo85
@aliengod: Again, this is coming from the guy who supports bigots because he think it would be better for his bank account lol.
How does it feel to hate yourself so much?
aliengod
@Giancarlo85: Don’t hate life so much kid. It will get better in time. Once your bitterness dissipates people will be kinder to you. You’ll learn as you grow and mature how to handle situations without lashing out. This awkward stage of puberty will pass before you know it.
Giancarlo85
@aliengod: You must be in such a bitter existence. You hate your gayness so much because it conflicts with your sexuality. You’ll never grow up.
Giancarlo85
@Giancarlo85: *Conflicts with your politics.
aliengod
@Giancarlo85: You’re doing good kid. Let it out. It’s not healthy holding all this anger inside. Keep it up. You’ll feel better soon.
Captain proton
8. Gandhi was a firm believer in the health benefits of Enemas and had one every morning throughout his adult life.
In this at least, it wouldn’t hurt Kim Davis to emulate him. maybe having all her shit forcibly removed on a daily basis will have a cumulative beneficial effect.
Giancarlo85
@aliengod: You’re such a child. You seem to have serious emotional problems. It’ll happen if you’re a republican.
martinbakman
If Francis-the-Talking-Pope gives away the Vatican’s billions of $ in gold the Catholic Church has swindled from people over the millennia, and then he agreed to be crucified for all the Fvcking horrible sins of the Catholic church committed over the years, decades and centuries,
then once his lifeless body is offered up as evidence of repentance, I might begin to give a Fvck about anything the Vatican says.
Jim McHardy
She is not worth even speaking of. What a horrible unchristian woman…..
Scott McIntosh
Gandhi was a sanctimonious fraud, as Churchill said ‘A seditious Middle Temple barrister’, with regressive views on civilisation and social development, whereas Davis…..er…..is not a barrister
Taskebab
Ghandi has made many anti-gay comments in his life though…don’t claim that Ghandi is so great when he would probably not have supported gay rights anyway
Bisexual-Transwoman
@Taskebab: I heard he was actually gay, bisexual, or even a ped0 but who knows if any of that is really true?
Gartholomew Nichols
Are we still on this?… yes Kim Davis is horrible now can we just get on with our lifes please :/
Giancarlo85
@Taskebab: Take into context the time period please. Not that India is all that accepting anyways… even today they are a regressive country.
JerseyMike
@William Russell: Leave her kid out of this.. very rude comment..
onthemark
8. Gandhi used to FAST. (This is the biggest difference between him and Kim Davis. She never skipped a meal in her life.) When he would break his fast, he used to polish off a box of Triscuits. Gandhi loved Triscuits!
9. Gandhi would put oil on his bald head and rub it all over his lovers’ bodies. Oh, the passion!
onthemark
Actually, Gandhi may have been GAY. There have been rumors for decades:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/12/india-government-buys-gandhi-letters-to-stop-auction_n_1668466.html
Kangol
@Taskebab: Gandhi was in love with another man, he was as gay or bi as many people on here.
@Captain proton: Kim Davis IS a walking enema, or to put it another way she’s a walking tube of sh!t.
@Scott McIntosh: Coming from the drunken imperialist that Churchill (who did win a major war, by the way) was, that’s a compliment to Gandhi!
GayEGO
Kim Davis is more of a fart in Sunday School! :>)
Saint Law
@aliengod: You confuse typing with thinking.