In a scathing indictment of New Jersey’s Emerson School District, the state’s attorney general Paula Dow says administrators there for six years ignored the obvious anti-gay bullying of student “‘J.C.” And she wants blood.
From middle through high school, J.C. was physically assaulted, had his life threatened (with kids telling him they’d slit his throat and shoot him at school), and regularly taunted with gay slurs. Drawings of J.C. performing gay sex acts were circulated among students. A faux Facebook profile was set up that identified J.C. as “female” and listed his sexual orientation as “unknown.” J.C.’s parents complained to the school at least 17 times, but not once were the parents of the bullies ever contacted by the school, the complaint says, nor were the students punished in any meaningful way.
Records indicate J.C. either left the school or graduated in 2007.
In a Finding of Probable Cause, Dow says administrators ignored the problems, and their negligence is inexcusable. If the school board is found guilty, it faces a $10,000 fine, mandatory policy changes and staff training, and possibly compensatory damages for J.C.. The school district’s attorney “categorically denies any bullying took place and that all complaints were handled appropriately.” Which is weird, because the school district said during the A.G.’s initial investigation that it was aware of the bullying but took steps to counter it. (Evidently, Dow’s office disagreed.)
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
The details are horrifying, relays NBC New York:
Among school officials singled out was former football coach and now Dean of Students Robert Carcich, who told investigators that he had handled many such complains, but that “he spokes to witnesses who failed to corroborate J.C.’s allegations. However, Carcich was unable to provide documentation to support his account.”
In detailing the gun threat, the AG’s office noted that Emerson police went to M.F.’s home to investigate “and a subsequent search of M.F.’s home resulted in the seizure of guns and knives belonging to both M.F. and his father.” M.F. was placed in a psychiatric facility for evaluation, but later released and allowed to return to school. J.C.’s father was told M.F. would not be allowed near his son, but then the two were scheduled to be in three classes during that school year. Superintendent Vincent Taffaro allegedly advised J.C.’s father he could seek a restraining order if he felt it was necessary.
Eventually, J.C. turned to home schooling after suffering from stress, went back to school after being assigned an aide to help avoid bullying situations, and according to the Finding, was still subjected to another incident by three other students within a month. That was it, and he finished the year with home schooling.
From here the case enters a process called Conciliation, and it could wind up in a non-jury law trial. But in the immediate? How about Emerson administrators — proudly touting being named a “High Performing District” — wise up to the fact that they are not immune to anti-gay student bullying, and they shouldn’t have to wait to get slapped with another action — based on the state’s soon arriving anti-bullying law — to get their shit together.
Otherwise, THESE KIDS KILL THEMSELVES. Jesus.
Michael
It seems late for the AG to be stepping in, now that JC has graduated. What’s up with the delay? This is going to make this case really difficult to prosecute. And parents? I still do not understand why parents do not confront each other in situations like this. These are your children, and you need to step in for them when others do not. It is your job! Lastly, when someone suggests “restraining order,” don’t delay – get one!
Aaron
I guess I don’t find this as shocking as others. This is basically the story of my life. Throughout school (until I started homeschooling at 6th grade), no matter where I moved, no matter how many schools I went to (and I went to 6 different ones) I was bullied without mercy. Verbally assaulted every day, occasionally physically assaulted, threatened with death frequently, etc. And ya no what? Nobody helped me. Ever. Oh sure, some kids got in trouble, but hah, when I finally stepped up and said “no, I’ll kill you before you do it to me!” not really meaning it and being fed up with shit, I’m the one who gets suspended. It doesn’t usually get better. Gay or straight or bisexual (I am Bi, but was not out and didn’t even know what the hell that meant) or transgender or whatever. There’s always those few kids who are going to be the black sheep, and who are made fun of by everybody- the school punching bag. It wont get better until teachers and principals actually ALL start caring. Where do you think all the kids get the justification to bully? From biased teachers. I tell you, it doesn’t ever look like its going to get better when you consider killing yourself at age fucking 7.
Vellis
The problem is that administrators like to take the
path of least resistance. If 1 student is bullying 1
student, then it is easy to punish the bully. If 25 students
are bullying 1 student, then it is easier to either ignore
or blame the victim, rather than try to discipline 25
culprits and then deal with 50 upset parents.
That is why these administrators have to be denied
discretion. Their response has to be made mandatory,
even if that means suspending a large number of students.
Admonisher
Hey Justin Robinette, don’t move to New Jersey LOL!
adman
I’ve never met anyone from Jersey who wasn’t a total ethical blank. That goes double for Long Island, let’s not even consider Florida.
Richie
17 times is 17 too many, it should never happen…My Sister has complained 50+ times about the bullying of my Nephew. Something needs to be done, pass the law Franken is pushing, kick the Bullies out right away. Do something to protect these kids.
scribe
@Aaron: I’m sorry that happen to you… Wish we went to the same high school, would have loved to have helped you out. I was bullied and eventually found the strength to fight back. My best friend in school was str8, but white and nerdy, which was all people needed to pick on him. I fought as many battles for him, as I fought for myself. Being bullied sucks, going through it alone is almost unbearable.
ATNNT
Adman : Actually, I find NJ and Long Island people pretty mixed, with lots of cool ones. They’re certainly more ethical than Manhattan people (but not as cool as Brooklyn, Queens, Bronx people). But I know we all have different experiences.
KC
My sister was a diabetic in grade school and she was tormented mercilessly by jackasses. They made fun of her having to have shots, at the foods she could not eat, the way she looked…..it made me sick. I was only one grade ahead of her but I kicked anyones ass that hurt her, and I was/am a girl. Girls threw rocks at her on the playground, they would throw her sweater up in the pipes in the bathrooms, make fun of her, you name it. Every time I was available, I came and became the bullys’ worst nightmare. I was not a big girl, was actually a gymnast and a cheerleader later, but I found out that you don’t HAVE to be big, all you have to do was fight back. All of them are cowards and none of them would bully when they were alone. It was/is a pack mentality. If any of my kids were bullied in school, I promise you, I would give the parents ONE notice, and even if I went to jail myself, I would dole out my own justice. I have never gotten over what my sister went through, and it has shaped my whole life to look out for the underdog. If I died tomorrow I would die knowing that I never let anyone get bullied in front of me. These days you might die from intervening, but then again, so might the offender. Sorry if I sound irrational, but this poor kid deserved so much better from his parents AND from the school, especially in this day and age and with so much awareness. I say let the “old school” justice prevail.
ATNNT
Good for you, KC. : )
ME
This makes me incredibly grateful for my school, though the students aren’t perfect, they are quite supportive of anyone despite anyones sexuality and there are about 35 people in the GSA (gay straight alliance) Club 🙂 I hop other schools improve and that ours gets even better.
declanto
Fight back! Revenge is as close to justice you can hope for.
Phil
@declanto: That’s a sad take on life. I’m sorry that you have to feel that way.
hephaestion
I was glad that “Glee” had Kurt leave his high school last night. All his friends promised to protect him, trying to convince him to stay. But he said “No. Nothing will change until they have a ZERO TOLERANCE OF BULLYING policy.” He was right.
Jonathan
@adman: I grew up in Florida. Ethical blank is an understatement. Soulless and stupid. I couldn’t wait to leave there.
Michael
@declanto: Where possible, “fight back,” or, learn to stand up for yourself is good advice. I realize this is not a popular stance, but, if you are going to make it in this world, you are going to need a backbone. Gay or straight, everybody must deal with “bullies,” – bad lovers, “friends,” bosses, family, business associates, you name it. People will walk all over you as long as you allow it. Things get better? Sure, but some personal effort is required.
adman
@Jonathan: I grew up in the LA area, which has become the same thing. Orange County? They probably give Nazi porn packs out in church to keep the sociopathic breeders interested in each other enough to reproduce and pay their tithes. Or maybe it just comes in the mail like supermarket flyers? Hang around with, or worse yet try to work with one for a day, and you’ll know where we are going politically as a country.
BeenThere
And all of you guys are complaining about white areas of the country. Try growing up in black society and schools, whether its Alabama or DC or Detroit. What goes on there against gays makes your complaints seem like amateur night.
PLAYS WELL WITH OTHERS
The only thing that makes bullies stop is confronting them standing up to them. For the vast majority they are insecure cowards who lust fear.
I had a friend in grammer school, Kyle who was the most adorable little kid who was also the queeniest little boy you could ever imagine. I am talking everytime Kyle opened his mouth a rainbow poured out with unicorns riding on it :p
His Parents knew at a very early age that Kyle was going to be a huge target for assholes. Rather than attempt to change him in any way his Parents made him join martial arts training. Kyle took to it like a swan to water. By age of 9 he was a fourth degree black belt………..
Through the years plenty of bullies singled out Kyle, only once. NOthing would give us greater pride and absolute pleasure than watching some asshole bully looking up at Kyle after his head stopped spinning and seeing standing over him after he was just knocked forcefuly on his fat ass. Kyle would offer the same advice each time: “You just got you one and only warning. Touch me or any other kid ever again and I promise I will act as stupid as you do”…………….