Escape Hatch

The DOMA Ruling Is A Gift To The GOP

The Republican party is a mess. In its rational moments (which are admittedly limited), the party recognizes that it has to change its attitudes, particularly on immigration and gay rights. Young Republicans have said the party has to drop the antigay rhetoric, and the establishment’s own post-mortem of the 2012 election admitted that the party will continue to lose young voters if it doesn’t change its homophobic tune. So it’s no surprise that the GOP’s national leaders are offering muted denunciations of the Supreme Court DOMA ruling. Secretly, they are thrilled that they can put the issue behind them.

The irony is that the Supreme Court would never have had to rule on DOMA at all if Congressional Republicans hadn’t pushed for their own lawyer to defend the law in court when the Obama administration said it wouldn’t. This is not the outcome those Republicans would have wanted. But it may be the best one for them.

“For all practical purposes, the combined rulings just about spell the sunset for the issue of marriage in national Republican politics,” John Ullyot, a Republican strategist and former longtime Senate aide told Buzzfeed. “Bottom line: in less than a decade, opposition to gay marriage has transformed from a marginal political winner for Republicans (see Ohio 2004) to a liability with swing voters in a decreasing number of competitive states.”

The key phrase there: “national Republican politics.” At the state and local level, there will be no shortage of GOP wingnuts who are intent on making a statement about their hatred of marriage equality. They will be front-and-center as marriage equality ballot measures spring up. They will also use marriage equality as red meat to rouse the conservative base. You can never been too conservative in the GOP this days, and what better way to prove it than gay bashing. That’s why you can count on some of the real right-wingers in Congress to make futile gestures, like introducing anti-marriage constitutional amendments that have zero chance of passing.

The Republican party will continue to be a mess for a long time. But the Supreme Court just gave the GOP a big gift–a way out of the demographic death spiral that it finds itself in. Already, Sen. Lindsey Graham has untied the ribbons. “In my view elected officials should be defining marriage, not judges, but the court has ruled and I respect the court,” he said. You can just about hear the sign of relief in his voice. Graham knows he just got a great present. The question will be whether the rest of the party also knows a good thing when it sees it.

Get Queerty Daily

Subscribe to Queerty for a daily dose of #politics #doma(defenseofmarriageact) #gop stories and more


  • MikeE

    GOP = Greedy One Percent

  • AxelDC

    I’d love for the GOP to try another 2004 antigay strategy. They know this is a lost battle. A majority of Americans support gay marriage. In the last year, 7 states have added gay marriage, including California. By 2016, there could easily be 25 states with gay marriage, and that now includes Federal rights.

    You really think the GOP wants to wage a strategy that alienates half the states and most Americans? I hope they try. It will all but guarantee President Hillary Clinton a compliant Congress.

  • 2eo

    @AxelDC: Agreed. The best thing that can happen is to keep poking and stirring the GOP hive as much as possible.

    Complacency allows these lunatics back into the game, they need kicking to the curb for good and riling them up is the way to do it. Don’t give them the chance to remake their image into something the public can stomach.

  • Dakotahgeo

    The GOP’S/TPotties’ absolute refusal to take the last two days as an unintended gift will be their demise. It’s almost as if they glory in their own pain and suffering… much like the “Christian Victims’ Cause” of the 2000s. Let them whine, curse, and grovel under the continuing boots of the New Republic. I’ve got two new pairs of shoes that need breaking in, and they have steel toes!

  • Cam

    One other issue, if the Supreme Court had made a sweeping decision that allowed gay marriage all over the country, the GOP might have gotten a last gasp of support from bigots. however, they wiped out CA’s prop 8, energized the gay rights movement for either another state by state fight, or lawsuits from legally married couples moving to anti-gay states under the full faith and credit clause.

    Both of these fire up the democrats. The Supreme Court would have done the GOP a much bigger favor if they had just legalized gay marriage nationwide. Keeping the fight going harms the GOP even more because their base won’t let them forget about it.

Comments are closed.