How does Wendy Williams annoy me? Let me count the ways. First, we can start with her bread and butter: passing judgment on dumb celebrities when her house is made of shattered glass. But everyone already calls her out on that.
The thing no one ever really calls her out on, though, is her tacit endorsement of toxic masculinity. Not to pass judgment on her the way she so gleefully does on everyone else, but it’s probably the reason why she spent so many years married to an allegedly typical toxic male. Her estranged unfaithful husband Kevin Hunter must have ticked all of the right “masculine” boxes for her.
Williams has made it crystal clear that her ideal type is a man’s man — someone who can love her, protect her, and, most importantly, dominate her … at least in size, because, well, it matters. Just in case the black women and gay men who make up the bulk of her audience didn’t get that from watching her show, she gave her gender specifics extra transparency in a recent episode where she discussed People magazine’s latest Sexiest Man Alive: John Legend.
Having toiled at People as a reporter and writer for most of the ’90s, I know firsthand the mathematics the editors apply in choosing a Sexiest Man Alive. That’s why I was surprised by the choice of John Legend. My first thought was this: His wife is funny, beautiful, and very quotable on social media, but can a solo Legend on the cover sell magazines? Do white mainstreamers really know him?
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
Wendy, however, questioned People’s choice for an entirely different reason during a recent “Hot Topics” segment of her talk show.
“When I think about a sexy man, I’m not thinking John Legend,” she said. “The first thing I think of is that I weigh so much more than him, and if we were walking down the street and somebody wanted to spray me with a water gun, I need a man who’s gonna punch someone in the face.”
Her pick for Sexiest Man Alive: Aquaman star Jason Momoa. I was inclined to agree until Wendy spilled the reason for her preference: “If, you know, I’m not quite feeling right after leaving the club, I need a man to throw me over his shoulder and say, ‘Come on girl — we’re going.’ John is not that guy.”
Enter Jason … or some superhero with enough muscle to lift Wendy off the ground. Clearly, “twinks” need not apply. Seriously, though, has there ever been a Sexiest Man Alive who looks capable of throwing Wendy Williams over his shoulder?
Her reasoning was such a thinly veiled – no, ringing — endorsement of toxic masculinity. Isn’t the guy she was describing also likely the one who is tough enough to physically intimidate a woman if necessary? Doesn’t he sound a bit like the bad guy women insist is the bane of womanhood, though, ultimately, what a girl wants, what she really really wants?
This brand of, well, toxic femininity is an insult not only to straight men who don’t fit the hyper-masculine mold — men like the one an entire episode of Sex and the City ridiculed (the one where Charlotte dated a man she decided had to be gay when he didn’t rescue her from a mouse) – are deemed too effeminate … or totally gay.
I just watched an episode of a show called Dollface on Hulu where one female character actually said to another: “If he doesn’t like you, he must be gay.” It wasn’t the comment that shocked me, but the fact that in this age of #MeToo, Time’s Up, and #BlackLivesMatter, a television script could still get away with such a thing. But then, LGBTQ always has ranked well under women and blacks in the hierarchy of beneficiaries of political correctness.
That’s why Ohio U.S. Senate candidate Melissa Acklson can call her opponent “a limp-wrist, weak-knee RINO” — implying what, I don’t know — and act defiant when the community calls her out on it. “I SAID what I SAID,” she tweeted, in response to the uproar. She knows the ramifications won’t be as brutal as they would have been if she had compared a black woman to an ape.
What ladies who promote crusty masculine stereotypes don’t realize is that they are doing as much damage to men who don’t live up to them as guys do to women when they treat them like second-class human beings because they aren’t sexy enough, because their breasts are too small, because they’re not men. When a rapper like Nicki Minaj roasts frock-wearing rapper Young Thug on her song “Barbie Dreams,” she’s not just dissing Young Thug. She’s insulting all of us who don’t conform to the traditional standards of manhood.
Many gay man have been hearing the “limp-wristed” and “sissy” slurs our entire lives, and when women casually toss them off, it’s as denigrating as when men talk to their breasts instead of to their faces. By complaining about aggressively flirty men in one breath and downgrading those who aren’t attracted to them as “gay” in another, they set up a confusing double standard: Don’t act like you want me, but if you don’t want me, then you must be gay.
The suggestion: You’re not a real man, so you don’t really count. Wendy Williams wasn’t saying that exactly, but by declaring that sexy is being bigger than her and being able to kick the butt of anyone who dares to mess with her, she was implying that any other kind of man is somehow lesser, not worthy of “sexy.” No-one calls her out on Twitter, though, because that’s actually the way more women than probably would like to admit it feel.
It’s part of our ancient tradition: the damsel in distress and the charming prince who rescues her. If sisters really are doing it for themselves, though, isn’t it time for them to let go of some of those creaky expectations that continue to hold back both them and us?
Jeremy Helligar is a New York City-based journalist from the U.S. Virgin Islands and the author of the travelogue/memoir Is It True What They Say About Black Men?
rustyiam
I wonder how people like Jeremy manage to get through life! He must be having mini breakdowns every 5 minutes! I’m embarrassed for him he is obviously threatened by a strong woman who has the confidence to express how she feels and is not intimidated by the mob! Oh and being a “reporter” for People magazine is something I’d leave out of my articles if you’re trying to impress your audience! Lastly Legend was chosen because he has a great publicist and fit in with the PC crowd!
Oranos
I just wonder how many Black men you know, cupcake.
Life, for us, demands a certain street smart/perceptiveness that escapes many readers – ones who aren’t Black, for example.
I get his point, and it’s a valid one.
As for Wendy Williams being a “strong woman,” if she’s so “strong,” why does she need a brother who’s bigger than her? Oh, right, she’s falling back on the stereotype of woman-needs-a-man-to-protect-her. She should meet Ripley (Aliens) or Sarah Connor (Terminator).
There are the truly strong Black women (Oprah, the late Toni Morrison, Maya Angelou) who don’t spend their time dissing other people. I like Williams, but she doesn’t fit in that group. If you think a gossipy, girl-did-you-notice-that Black woman fits what WE Black people see as “strength,” you are wildly mistaken.
Sister Bertha Bedderthanyu
Jeremy, if you really were a reporter for People Magazine I can understand how you do qualify for being able to judge who the sexiest man alive would be chosen. John Legend comes up very flat “back there” and looks like a clown without makeup no matter who’s show he and that talentless plastic looking cosmetic surgery laced wife of his appear on. As for Ms. Williams I thought she looked like a poorly dressed fool in that short dress she wore while interviewing Robin Crawford the week before last. Its was obvious thru the entire interview she was trying to taunt Robin to look at her crotch area, which thankfully (or hopefully) Robin saw thru what she was trying to do and didnt fall for it. Wendy should have been cancelled at least five years ago. She has nothing but D rated actors on her show, the type whose publicity agents get trash tabloids such as the NYPost or NYDaily News to make mention of once and you never hear anything else about them again. Thanks for calling out this obnoxious looking drag queen passing itself off as a woman.
MISTERJETT
you’ve obviously never seen the nude photos going around of Mr. Legend. he’s got a nice bubble butt. he is more little boy sexy and i can understand why he was chosen.
marion
Quite the hypocritical, judgemental ans hate filled article. Very Wendyesque
Josh447
Josh447
‘Fk me and protect me’ is the mantra of alot of women, it’s in the DNA, no use complaining. That’s not toxic anything, that’s just plain survival.
One of my best friends growing up was what some would call a limp wristsed fgt. But get in the way of his right hook and you were toast. He reminds me of that vid that is circling right now of that womp az gay kid who takes down his abuser in a class room in front of students. Bam. Down. Game over. That’s what my friend was like.
We just forced gay marriage down half the country’s throats, it’s gonna take a while to set in, like hundreds of years in the paternal US. With that and abortion in mind is it any clue why the republican senators won’t impeach and shtcan Trump? At least right now. He’s stacking the courts like no ones bizz.
Relax and understand the ride is rocky for a while. It’s just the lay of the land. Have compassion that phobias need time to evolve. Hearts rarely change over night.
boymikefl
Wendy can like the Neanderthal type AKA her ex. Dumb as rocks. I myself, like the young, thin, preferably latino boys. Eh, to each his or her own. Leave Wendy alone, hater.
WashDrySpin
Wendy is a C You Next Tuesday
TheMarc
Acklson’s and Wendy’s comments are completely different things; and you should know that. Your articles are always quite verbose, but rarely have any substance or back up your assertions very well. And this article is no different. There is absolutely nothing “toxic” about Wendy saying she prefers a larger guy vs someone like John Legend. There are plenty of women who would prefer John Legend over Jason Momoa, believe it or not, and there nothing “toxic” about that either. She’s speaking in regard to what she likes; not downing all other men who don’t fit in that category. If you’re always looking for an attack, you will always find one, apparently.
If this article was only about Acklson’s comments, it would have had a bit of genuine merit; but since it was only a paragraph in this novel, it makes the whole article fall flat and reek of some personal insecurities.
jonasalden
“But then, LGBTQ always has ranked well under women and blacks in the hierarchy of beneficiaries of political correctness.” you say? Except for the lynchings and rapes, I guess. The only thing Will and Jack had to do to survive was butch up. Can’t bleach yourself into invisibility or cut off your breasts without bleeding to death. Funny how the race to bottom place is now the thing to do. You remind me of Asian-Americans who sat on the sidelines during the heaviest of fighting for equality, CHOOSING to make like mice in the corner, but now shout their “minority-ness” from the rooftops. So hollow. NOW LET ME BE CLEAR, no one should have to pretend to be anything but who they are (neither Will nor Jack), but the statement I quoted from the main article just fell wrong to my ears.
splunky
The fact that you believe that Will & Grace mirrors the lives and struggles of gay people just proves to me that you are someone who needs to stop watching so many sitcoms. On a positive note, your comment did make me laugh. Pure comedy.
gymmuscleboy
Why is a man capable of throwing you over his shoulder necessarily toxic? That is the premise of your conclusion, and it makes no sense.
Josh447
I agree. His comment seems a bit knee Jerk. Not well thought out.
PLAYS WELL WITH OTHERS
Isn’t Wendy Williams a Drag Queen??
bonbon
There’s absolutely nothing sexy about John Legend.
Kangol2
To you. That juicy azz he’s got is sexy AF to quite a lot of people.
Bob LaBlah
It wouldn’t shock me to learn Jason Momoa “experimented” in his teen years. There is something about him that gives me that vibe (and I’m sorry that it wasn’t with me because the man is HOT).
BiDaddyDude
So, is Queerty going to talk about the fact Rich Juzwiak of Jezebel and other sites is being accused of sexual harassment by three men of color? It’s true.
Donston
You couldn’t come up with a less corny and generic handle? This isn’t a porn site. Furthermore, we already know who you are. Not fooling anyone.
chupacabra
dumbston…. you obviously dont
richard 14
Toxic feminism is also an insult to gay men.
Esscourt
I think each of Wendy Williams’ boobs should have its own zip code.
nitejonboy
Wendy Williams is a piece of trash, and that’s why so many gay men watch her..sad but true, we love a good trainwreck. I will never understand it. It’s just sad.
chupacabra
what and ugly nasty bitch
MISTERJETT
i use to say i would watch Wendy until she says something stupid and i usually only watch for the first few minutes until i turned the channel. now i don’t even watch her any more. i came to realization that everything she says is stupid.
MISTERJETT
as for Wendy, all she seems to talk about is housewives of someplace or other and hip hop artist, all of whom i know nothing about. i stopped watching her a long time ago. i don’t like her interviewing style. i’m not an Oprah fan either, but she does give a good interview. as soon as you disagree with Wendy on anything, she gets an attitude.