Unfolding Scandal Reveals Catholic Church Castrated At Least 11 Dutch Boys For Being Gay In 1950s

Evidence has emerged implicating the Catholic Church in the Netherlands of routinely castrating boys who were gay in the 1950s— especially, it seems, if those boys were involved in accusing priests of sexual abuse.

The Netherlands’ NRC Handelsbad reported over the weekend that it had discovered testimony surrounding the case of Henk Heithuis, who was castrated in 1956 at the age of 18. After making reports to police about sexual abuse by priests at his Catholic boarding house, Helthuis was transferred to a Catholic psychiatric hospital, where the castration took place. (Helthuis was killed in an auto accident in 1958.)

The story was uncovered as part of the research surrounding last December’s Deetman Commission Report, which investigated the systematic abuse of children at the hands of the Catholic Church from 1945 to 2010. NRC Handelsbad discovered evidence of at least ten other instances of youth castration besides Helthuis’s—though those cases all involved anonymous victims. None, including the Helthuis case, made it into the final Deetman report.

The surgical removal of testicles was considered not only a treatment for homosexuality, but also a punishment for those who had accused clergy of sexual abuse, sources told the investigating reporter. On Monday, it was revealed that government inspectors knew of the castration going on in Dutch Catholic psychiatric hospitals, but did nothing to stop it.

The UK’s Telegraph reports that Dutch MPs will today call for an independent investigation into the castration allegations.

“We must find out how many cases there were, who knew about it, and why the government did not act,” said Labour MP Khadija Arib.