What If It Turns Out Empire State Building Shooter Jeffrey Johnson Was Gay?

What you’re about to read is (mostly) conjecture and traffics in stereotypes. If you’re offended or confused by that, well, we have a slideshow of boys frolicking poolside you can check out.

When we heard someone had started firing their pistol outside the Empire State Building, just 12 blocks from where literary masterpieces pour forth from our fingers, we first thought it was  a psychotic on a shooting spree. (After all, terrorists usually prefer bombs.)

But when we heard that the man who walked up and killed his ex-boss in cold blood this morning worked in fashion—and the papers didn’t mention a wife—our mind went to a whole different place: What if the gunman was gay?

There hasn’t been any concrete evidence Jeffrey Johnson, 58, was a homosexual—no lover, friends or bartender have stepped forward. But when you grew up, like we did, seeing gay people reduced to short-hand stereotypes—fiftysomething, unmarried, designed women’s accessories—your thoughts just drift in a certain direction.  Local outlets even referred to Johnson with baited terms like “slight-framed,” and “subdued.”

And, well, he owned a cat. (We told you this wasn’t going to be politically correct.)

Chatting with our best girlfriend, who lives a stone’s throw from the ESB on 30th and Park, we found he had the same thought: “People will think it’s the start of a gay shooting-spree epidemic!”

Never mind that Johnson only shot one person, his boss. (The rest of the bullets were fired by trigger-happy members of the NYPD).

Of course, it’s not really about whether Johnson was gay or not—is certainly doesn’t matter to the family of his victim, Steve Ercolino. It’s about how, if he was, his sexuality will be used to drive the narrative. If Johnson was indeed a fiend of Dorothy, will that give fuel to the FRC and their ilk, who can now brand us as violent in addition to crazy and evil? Or might it make them think twice about pissing off an angry queen?

Share your thoughts in the comments.

Photos: MySpace, jonraewan

Get Queerty Daily

Subscribe to Queerty for a daily dose of #crime #empirestatebuilding #jefreyjohnson stories and more


  • Larkin

    “Fiend of Dorothy”… lolz

  • Cam

    So now Queerty is not only ignoring reporting on attacks against the gay community and reporting people who make the gay community look bad, they are now inventing stories to tar and feather the gay community.

    But you know Dan, nice try to claim that anybody who notices that should go look at pictures of frolicking boys.

    So in one fell swoop you both admitted you knew what you were doing with this story, but you also insulted your own website.

    Well played Dan, Well Played.

  • Joe Dalmas

    Guys, you HAVE GOT to learn the difference between “your” and “you’re”, “”there” and “their”, etc. I love your articles but, for God’s sake, get your writing right. Hugs.

  • Rockery

    LMAO!!! What if he is gay? What is this all about? I don’t get the point of this story

  • Red Meat

    Gay people can be psychotic criminals too? You don’t say?!

  • Aidan8

    Help me understand how this article somehow helps avoid the FRC “driving the narrative.” Innuendo, speculation, talking with a friend “who lives in the area”…… really?

  • hamoboy

    Then homophobes will start the “them gays are murderous killers!” meme, and maybe it will teach the white gays commenting here why it’s as much of a meme, and not necessarily true, as the “them blacks are homophobic killers!” meme that is alive and well on these comment threads. Hopefully commenters will learn to stop stereotyping people based on their background, and start looking for real reasons behind the atrocities.
    When somebody does something like this, you don’t blame everyone who shares a minority status that they do, you blame the individual responsible!

  • niles


  • gattsuru

    There’s been Freepers bringing up the possibility… to imply that an unemployed New York fashion designer might also have voted Democratic — queue surprised gasp. The information we have is very incomplete, but it tells a story of Office Space-stapler-dude, and that’s not really compelling in the media as a story about gay people.

    If the FRC want to play martyrs, they can cherry-pick stuff far more tailor-made for such than this, if only by benefit of extreme cherry-picking.

  • randallreynolds

    Whether or not the shooter was gay, LGBT Humans deserve civil rights.

  • pac6395

    If he was gay and they try to pin down this fact on “angry homosexual” and make the LGBT community look bad we could just bring up the fact that look at the past few shootings in the las month. All done by heterosexuals. End of point.

  • Eric Auerbach

    Totally off-topic: Love the new look, but if you *really* want to take the page to the next level, you should (a) allow edits in the comments, and (b) allow likes.

  • Burlington

    ” Friend of Dorothy “? Let’s hope not… It’s sad. A sad news for everyone. I’m tired, I’m sick of stories like this.

  • Neo

    As I have said before, one of the analytical and advertising tools used by Queerty is Outbrain, a right wing tech company with ties to the mormon church, their number one asset in the US is the fox news site.

  • rhino79

    He wasn’t gay. The designs on his website are of classic cars, girls on motorcycles, old airplanes, etc. Definitely just a lonely, weird straight dude, angry that the hunky Italian Stallion emasculated him. Meanwhile, hundreds are dying daily in Syria…

  • ncman

    Hey Queerty…. as usual you need a bit of editing. In this statement:

    “Chatting with our best girlfriend, who lives a stone’s throw from the ESB on 30th and Park, we found he had the same thought:”

    You got your pronoun a bit screwed up. If your best “girlfriend” a man? Or, have you just fallen in to the trap of using female references for gay men?

  • Kit McCollum

    This post is just blatantly irresponsible and should be removed.

  • mulletkitty

    It’s perfectly acceptable to hypothesize, particularly to allow for discussion, as queers, of how to respond to the inevitable “gays gone wild” narrative that would have resulted had he been gay.

    But the details emerging — a nerdy manchild who overestimated his job talent, expected too high a salary for his mediocre skills, and was obsessed with drawing cartoons of buxom women, hot rod cars, and fighter jets — suggests this is not gonna be the case.

  • BJ McFrisky

    Ironic that the MSM hasn’t implied anything about Johnson’s sexuality, but leave it to Queerty to inject sexuality into the matter. If there’s any blowback toward the gay community for this, we’ll have Queerty and Dan Avery to thank for getting the ball rolling.

  • Mr. Enemabag Jones

    I was excited when Queerty came back online. After reading this article, not so much.

  • nicoinnz

    Actually that’s what I thought too. Can’t help it! The loner, the cat, the visiting mummy. Although you forgot the vacuuming he did at breakfast time. So gay. Yep, the type A italian workplace hardass just got a little too much. Total clash of personalities couldn’t leave them at home for the better of the company. Sorry people but I loved the way this was written. You were warned and hey, poolside bimbos are on offer.

  • GeriHew

    Perhaps he was an occasional autosexual transvestite in the privacy of his own home.

    I don’t really feel his website offers that many clues as to the true nature of his sexuality.

    He may of course have had other websites that do.

  • alexoloughlin

    Assuming that he is gay is tantamount to saying all catholic priests might be gay because they’re not married and many are old. Even if the guy is gay, so what? Does anyone question the orientation of a straight murderer or rapist and is it relevant to the crime? Absurd notion, Queerty.

  • the other Greg

    Even if he was gay, so what? The police shot so many people that it’s become a police scandal, and will be remembered for that and nothing else.

  • MartinDK

    What is the point of this article? Using every imaginable incident as a context for speculating gays might be hated on is what…. Paranoia?
    Report the news or do features, please. That’s interesting to read. Conjecture and paranoia just sucks…

  • schlukitz


    As a long time member of Queerty whose comments are frequently moderated for defending my GLBT brothers and sisters, I am shocked and appalled by this editorial.

  • esmale

    “Paper didn’t mentioned wife”…..means….gay???? totally disgusting.

Comments are closed.