Former reality TV star/antigay activist Josh Duggar’s legal team is trying anything and everything they can think of to get his child porn case tossed out, and their latest strategy might be their most ridiculous yet.
Duggar was arrested back in April when the IP address linked to the used car dealership where he worked was used to download over 200 photos and videos of children in compromising and abusive situations.
Last week, Duggar’s lawyers filed a motion requesting that the case against him be dismissed, arguing that it was actually one of the other employees from the dealership, not Duggar, who accessed the illegal content.
Yahoo! News reports:
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
Duggar’s team sought to cast blame on a person identified in court documents as Witness #1. Federal agents interviewed Witness #1 in December 2019, roughly one month after authorities first executed a search warrant at the dealership.
According to court documents, federal agents originally designated Witness #1 a “person of interest to the investigation.”
Witness #1 told the investigators that he worked at Duggar’s dealership, and had even stayed there overnight “without Duggar’s knowledge or permission,” Duggar’s lawyers said.
Witness #1 also “admitted to viewing adult pornography through websites he accessed through the internet on his cellular phone,” though he denied viewing child pornography, according to the court filing.
There’s just one teeny tiny glaringly obvious hole in Josh’s new defense.
Investigators already searched Witness #1’s device and determined that it was “negative” for any child pornography. They also searched the devices of two other employees, identified as Witness #2 and Witness #3, and drew the same conclusion.
That only leaves Josh’s phone, which allegedly contained hundreds and hundreds of kiddie porn files.
Of course, his lawyers have an explanation for this as well. They say he didn’t download the files to his phone. Instead, they were somehow transferred there from one of the other three employee’s devices to make him look guilty. Or something. Oh, and not only that, but investigators didn’t do a good enough job preserving the evidence, so now nothing can be proven, so the whole case should be thrown out.
“The problem is that [DHS’ Homeland Security Investigations division] may have not identified evidence of child pornography during the field examination of these devices — but failed to preserve other potentially exculpatory evidence,” the motion says.
Duggar’s legal team filed a series of other motions as well, including one asking that pictures of his hands and feet that were taken during his arrest not be included in his trial, saying authorities didn’t have a warrant to photograph any of his body parts.
You know you’re grasping at straws when you’re best defenses are basically “I’ve been framed but I can’t prove it because the evidence has all been lost!” and “You can’t take pictures of my feet!”
Duggar has pled not guilty to the child pornography charges against him. His trial date, originally scheduled for July 6, was rescheduled for November 30. If convicted, he faces up to 20 years in federal prison and over $250,000 in fines.
Graham Gremore is the Features Editor and a Staff Writer at Queerty. Follow him on Twitter @grahamgremore.
Trekbike
A born sexual predator from beginning to end.
Cam
There is something dark about that family. I would not be shocked to find out that Josh was molested as a child and that their church is packed with sexual predators.
Liquid Silver
19 (Molestations) And Counting
Mack
CAM, I really have to say I agree with you. I’ll bet he was molested if not by the minister, his father. This whole “Christian” group is a problem.
letthemeatcake
What a low-life scumbag. Send him down the rabbit hole, then clean it out with napalm
Tombear
Hey, it’s a straight male fundamentalist thing. The young preachers want to ram the love of Jesus Christ INTO young girls. Child molesters run rampant in Fundamentalist churches. Praise the Lord!
BoomerMyles
That’s Xtian fundies for you.
Hope he adores the crucifixion because that’s what the jury will do to him.
Cozmo2
I wall ways new there was something wrong with that family. What did you expect them kids to do. They can’t do anything without a chaperone. They where probably told as teenagers not to masturbate because if you do god will punish you. That’s why the boys are marrying so young. I feel sorry for the kids growing up like that.
radiooutmike
They marry so young because that is what religion dictates.
But like Matthew McConaghey in Dazed and Confused, those girls keep getting younger…or whatever that movie quote was…
jerjn
Oh, he pled not guilty, did he?
Thats a LIE, and LYING is SIN.
Seth
He’s just out there making White Jesus proud.
cuteguy
Religion is a cult. God is love. Once ppl differentiate religion from God, they will live much happier lives
Tombear
I love the fact Jesus was a Jew. Some Evangelical Christians can’t accept that.