
AB: What's the importance of myths? Why do we have them or need them?
AC: Myths are the very foundation of culture. We mold ourselves to the myths we read and hear; we live through them. We become them. If you look at a child growing up today, he is constantly being exposed to the myth of boy-girl romance. It can be in a story, it can be in a movie, it can be in a commercial – but when it comes to boy-boy romance, there is a huge gaping hole. Utter silence!
But children will have those feelings anyway. Why should they be left without guidance? What is the meaning of culture if not the evolution of human thought and behavior? Love has a culture, too. Why should boys who love other boys have to build up a culture from scratch every time? So you might say that the importance of these myths in particular is that they return to the missing half of our love culture. And not just for gay people, for everyone with the courage to face that side of themselves.
Maybe if I had read these myths when I was young, I would have been known how to show my love and live my love in ways that I simply was not able. The more I study these myths, the more I see in them the Greek's loving guidance: how to love, how to be loved, how not to hurt your lover or beloved. On a deeper level, there are spiritual teachings there as well, about the importance of surrendering the self in order to be fully yourself, but that is another topic.
AB: What's your opinion of pederasty – that is, the social institution in which younger men were paired with older men?
AC: That is a loaded question. The word "pederasty" has been misused in so many ways. People today think of pederasty as an illegal act with an underage child. If we look at the Greeks, we see that they loved law, they saw it as the only thing that separated civilization from barbarism. The pederasty they admired was lawful pederasty, between a man and a youth who had come of age. There is no real difference between our cultures as far as that goes – they had an age of consent; we have an age of consent. If anything, they were more protective of their children than we are: inferior people were not allowed to become their lovers, anal sex was not supposed to take place, and the father kept an eye on things.
So if you are asking me what I think of lawful pederasty today – that which takes place between an older man and a much younger beloved who is of age, something that is legal today everywhere – I will say that it can be wonderful and empowering and enlivening for both.
There is a real magic to a relationship between unlike partners, between lovers who are able to leap that gap between the generations, and who complement each other instead of just mirroring each other. Oscar Wilde, when he was in the dock at Old Bailey, said it very well: it is the love between a younger and an older man, when the older one has wisdom and culture, and the younger has the all beauty and energy of youth.
AB: I'm 26 – so, if I were dating a fifty or forty year old man – would that be pederasty? Is it the age or the dynamic that makes a relationship pederastic?
AC: Well, Bosie, Oscar Wilde's beloved, was in his early twenties, if I am not mistaken. And Oscar certainly thought their relationship was pederastic, as did Bosie. And if you look at most of the youths depicted on the Greek pederastic vases, these were not scrawny kids, they were well developed young men.
Yes, we should probably say that it is the difference in age that creates that dynamic, but it is not necessary, and probably not desirable, especially if that difference is so great that underage youths are involved.
There has to be a certain consciousness there too, that dynamic you point to: there has to be a certain kind of nurturing and generosity on the part of the older lover, a certain melting of the heart. And the youth too has to be devoted – it really is a two-way thing. If you do not have reciprocity, you do not have pederasty. You have something else.
AB: How did you go about gathering the information and putting all the pieces together to compile your book?
AC: Most of the stories of Greek mythology that we come across in books and movies have not been preserved whole, but were pieced together from fragments found here and there, some written hundreds of years apart. It was no different with these stories. It just so happens that nobody had done that yet – the stories were too embarrassing and too dangerous to one's academic career. But the times have changed, and I think it is simply an idea whose time has come. If I had not done it, someone else would have. It is like that with ideas.
Maggie Gallagher’s Maine Condolence Letter Will Surely Cause You to Tear Up (58)
· Quake says: We lost by a small scale, the young generation is getting it. The old people can die... »
The DNC Totally SCREWED US OVER in Maine. And Then Lied About It (38)
· Charles Merrill says: Bill Perdue There is always going to be the uber rich, it’s the nature... »
Were These Dads Harassed + Detained By Wal-Mart Because They’re Gay? (28)
· Quake says: I bet you while all the Walmart workers surrounded this couple about 5 other people... »
Can’t A Television Show Say ‘Fag’ Anymore Without GLAAD Getting Upset? (85)
· Robert, NYC says: Chris, Andy…exactly what I was trying to bring out in my previous posts.... »
MJ Back In The Saddle (12)
· alajdia says: I haven’t seen you for weeks. buy cheap nolvadex http://www.stumbleupon... »
Is It Wrong to Refuse to Have Sex With HIV-Positive Men? (100)
· Sydney says: I agree with #38. Much rather be an asshole about it than willingly get sick. »
We Love It When Neil Patrick Harris Gets ROUGH (4)
· arnau says: I first heard “messages of dates” just when NPH’s pic appears on his... »
The Big Problem If ENDA Doesn’t Stipulate What Changes Must Be Made to Employee Bathrooms (7)
· jason says: There is no such thing as a “trans gender”. Your gender is either male or... »
· Dr. Jillian T. Weiss says: Reply to WHAT’s comment: You say that I don’t “answer... »
PHOTOS: He’s a Good Cristian (1)
· dvlaries says: Quite a sturdy set to start the week with. Thanks too for weeding out any shots with... »
There is an exact replica, originally made in Italy and transported to the U.S., of the statue Andrew Calimach describes in my high school auditorium in Winston-Salem, N.C. It was so cool to read about Calimach's story and how he saw the original as a child. Seriously, my high school, built by the widow of tobacco tycoon R.J. Reynolds (Camel cigarettes, you know?), spared absolutely no expense or frill when being furnished.
I hope this book and indeed this author gets queers thinking about two things:
1. Apart from the mythological queerdom of Ancient Greece, sexual relationships between younger and older men were an integral and dynamic force in society: succesful relationships rooted in mutual and community responsibility.
2. The need to abolish arbitrary and unrealistic age-of-consent laws, as defined by our deeply homophobic cultures which use it as the ultimate weapon to keep queers "in line" by allegedly "protecting children".
Queers of all ages need to clearly understand that legally cutting the heart out of the current toxic, sick and hateful U.S.-style pedophile witch-hunts is fundamental to cutting out the homohatred which is being learned by adolescents in school, as taught by so-called "protectors" and policed using cut-off ages which are not remotely appropriate to sexual or emotional development or decided upon with input from the age group(s) being "protected".
This is not an issue to be danced around or denied out of fear of being labelled as pro-pedophile. It's the core issue which needs to be attacked head-on in order for us to once and for all gut the power of those who will always criminalize us with the most devious methods they can use.
What a wonderful interview, thanks for sharing with us!
I can't wait to read the book "Lover's Legends" myself, now. And I appreciate Calimach's words of wisom regarding the rather taboo topic of androphile relationships that have an age gap. Without too much detail, I know that when a young man can find wisdom and mentorship with older partners who provide guidance, it can be a wonderful force in one's life.
It'd be nice to see the Greek myths without all the gay stuff censored.
However … I really doubt the myths were meant as a guide to loving, or how to love, or how to not hurt your lover. That's putting a bit too much modern new age / Hallmark spin on things. Read Homer: Mortals who loved the gods suffered and came to bad ends.
wow. you guys have great stuff! I really enjoyed reading this…thank you.