To refresh the memories of those who didn’t watch the first season: Patrick (Jonathan Groff) is the clean-shaven one who botched his relationship with a nice boy and then started sleeping with his partnered boss, Dom (Murray Bartlett) is the mustachioed older dude who has an even older boyfriend (Lynn) but likes sex with younger men, and Agustin (Frankie J. Alvarez) is the bearded one with a self-destructive side. The first eight episodes, though met with acclaim from many in the gay community, were also dogged by criticism: it was sexless, not “gay” enough, and (most dreaded of all) boring.
A new era dawns in the sophomore season’s premiere when the three leads decide to have a cozy weekend away in Lynn’s cabin. I mean, sure, that doesn’t sound like an auspicious start, but that’s just a lighthearted meta-jab at the critics. “Get it, guys? We’re doing something dull!” There’s actually a scene in which the three main characters play Monopoly, the uncontested champion of tedium disguised as entertainment. That is straight-up writer-on-audience trolling.
Unlike last year, however, Babyface and Mustache are pretty open about their disapproval of Beardo’s constant misbehavior. Though they avoid the flailing melodrama that would tempt so many other shows, they’re at least cognizant enough of his constant petulance to do things like casually chide him for his sass and wimpily suggest that maybe we won’t drink this weekend. Ag’s personality has also cooled down a little since last season, so he seems more believably like your slightly misguided friend and less like the neighborhood sex-addicted sociopath.
Which is not to say that the characters aren’t still up to their old tricks. Patrick remains the naïve boy scout he always was. He wants to walk through the forest to see an old tree; when the group kayaks past a clothing-optional beach, he clutches his imaginary pearls. Agustin, on the other hand, might as well be building a Fleshlight out of the pot he promised he wouldn’t bring on the trip. He wants to get fucked against the old tree (and every other tree); when they kayak past the clothing-optional beach, he clenches his imaginary anal beads. Dom is more pensive on the trip, perhaps because the writers are still figuring him out, but perhaps because that outer calm is what it looks like when you have your shit together. I honestly wouldn’t know.
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
Things get interesting when Dom’s roommate Doris magically materializes at the cabin. The complete absence of logical explanation for her arrival makes her seem like the group’s foul-mouthed fairy godmother, which is probably the best way to sum her up. She slices through everyone’s façade with more insight and humor than most other shows could cook up in an entire season. This is a woman who could make Monopoly exciting. And, like any good fairy godmother, she’s going to turn the night around.
In another “we can hear you” moment from the writers, Doris leads our motley crew into the woods for an all-night drug binge ass blast marathon. Here’s all the sex you wanted in season one! Because if there’s anything lesbians love, it’s open-air man-on-man orgies. Patrick switches inexplicably from “let’s not drink” to “sure, Molly sounds fantastic,” and then proceeds to convince his boss (Russell Tovey, whose ears all of my Facebook friends want to sodomize) to drive to meet him so they can have more ill-advised fluid exchange. Dom’s pectorals (who should really get separate billing in the credits they’re so magnificent) come out to play, and then he goes down on a dude who mistakes Lynn for his father. Though he doesn’t freak out in the moment, you have to wonder if that comment will shatter the cool exterior he’s been portraying. Gays and aging don’t always mix well.
Agustin, however, gets the most surprising overnight encounter. Escaping from the mayhem, he starts making positive life choices by connecting in a genuine way with a handsome heavyset gentleman (Mean Girls‘ Daniel Franzese) who works with at-risk gay youth. The fact that he can overlook his suitor’s size (large) and HIV status (positive) says a lot about the emotional growth that must have happened over the summer. Old Ag would have spoken to this man only to tear him down; New Ag goes romantically skinny dipping with him instead. (If Big Bear Boyfriend didn’t have a beard, though, I feel like he might have struck out.)
With the next morning’s sunrise comes the sobering truth. Patrick has to confess that butt stuff with his supposedly-in-a-monogamous-relationship workplace superior is not his brightest-ever idea. Dom has to recognize that he’s in love with an old dude who has a really ugly portrait of himself on display in the living room. Agustin has to go through that thing at the end of How the Grinch Stole Christmas where his heart grows two sizes. The audience has hope that Doris made it home OK, because she doesn’t appear in the final montage. Don’t worry, she’s probably not dead. This isn’t a season of American Horror Story. Then again, they are making a lot of changes around here…
enlightenone
The writers of this show are deaf, dumb, and mute! Get the “Girls” writers to do this show or scrap it all together. Not good for intelligent, mature gay men or gay youth. I guess great for straight folk?
odawg
One word: TERRIBLE! It’s really bad when two minutes into a 25 minute show you are bored.
Faulk
I wasn’t bored even for a sec? What are those people above me talking about? O.O
The first episode was just perfect, i loved every second off it! 😀
Cam
It looks like the people who make “Looking” read Queerty, or at least the comments.
Augustine has had a personality transplant. He still has his issues, but this season they have decided to make him behave nice once in a while, actually acting like a real person. So apparently either the actor or the director got the message that making somebody have zero redeeming qualities doesn’t work if we are supposed to believe he is able to maintain friendships.
And just in case we didn’t get the message that this may still be Augustin’s body but there is a differeing person living in it, they hammer home the point by giving him a possible new boyfriend, not skinny, works with at risk kids and is HIV positive. They weren’t taking any chances on us not knowing that he is now different.
Groff’s character still seems to be floating on the wind, I’m not sure Groff is able to play optimistic without seeming childish but they at least don’t have him acting like he has never seen a penis before.
Dom’s character, pretty much the same, but not really seeming to like his bf that much.
And all of you who like diversity will be over the moon. Yes, they got rid of Augustin’s boyfriend who, while also being the only black character on the show, was also the most fully realized character other than Ritchie, AND Groff, while working in the IT industry in SF still manages not to have any gay Asian friends, but it’s ok fans of diversity, why? Because Dom hooked up with a black guy. So, you know, that’s the same right? 😉
I tease (Bitch) but I will say that this episode seems like they might be going in a somewhat less irritating direction than last year.
It still is weird to me that TV seems unable to just let a character go. Why not have the friends phase Augustine out as any normal group of friends would do to somebody so unpleasant and just stay friends with his boyfriend? Real life is like that, in real life the cast of “Friends” wouldn’t still be living with each other for 100 years.
sportyguy1983
How did this god awful show get a 2nd season?
lykeitiz
I’ll keep watching with optimism, but it still doesn’t seem to be going anywhere. The characters don’t seem fully realized, which is OK for a sitcom, but not for a drama. It has an empty, not “real” feel to it.
With Queer As Folk, even people who hated the show did so mostly because it reminded them of people they didn’t like. That’s still proof of an accurate portrayal. The guys on “Looking” are more like caricatures, not characters.
MarionPaige
@enlightenone:
some of the writers for Looking are writers for Girls, at least this was the case for Season 1. The best PR Looking has done to date was an interview with the writers for Looking. The writers made a very big impression in their interview and they genuinely appear to be trying to bring their real world gay experiences to Looking.
I’ve never seen Girls and have no plans to.
Len John
This show is absolutely delightful. Not like we have a lot to choose from. If you want to watch a piece of total crap, you can always check out “Modern Family” where the two most pathetic neutered gay men in history win Emmy Awards.
blueshirt409
@sportyguy1983: And how did one of its episodes get a long article on Queerty? It’s longer than the episode!
enlightenone
@MarionPaige: “…I’ve never seen Girls and have no plans to.”
No disrespect, but if you have no intention of watching Girls then I don’t think you would appreciate me saying the writers who wrote for Looking from Girls must have been from their writing stable who were complaining about when then would have their script filmed! And now we, at least I, see/read the results.
NG22
I loved the premiere! I should add that I loved the first season as well. I binge-watched it on Saturday in advance of Sunday’s premiere. It’s even better the second time around.
I think my favorite scene was Patrick and Dom talking to each other on the bed. They have such an easy, relaxed, faintly sensual chemistry. I love seeing them interact.
The show is engrossing, contemplative, thoughtful, warm, hot, and beautifully-filmed. It has a tone that is singular on American television. I watch it and I am just fascinated and intrigued. I find it to be smart and subtle. I never want the half-hour to end.
Kisses to the full cast and crew. For me, the show is a joy to watch. I certainly hope the critical acclaim leads to award recognition. Bravo!
redcarpet30
Not a good start, still seems like the same show. Sad cuz I thought it just needed to hit its stride but still seems so tame and boring. The entire episode ammounted to “Lets go to the woods and relax but who are we kidding lets take molly and go to a gay bar in the woods!” The end!
I don’t think the format of the show lets it tell the story it’s trying to tell. Hell, I’m not even sure they know what they want to say other than “We are NOT QAF!”
Daniel-Reader
It’s a great show because it’s following these three particular characters rather than trying to be a bland be-all show. The character development and backstories are more subtly revealed, like the painting on the wall, which was clearly done by the old dead boyfriend in the photo album.
Cam
Ok, My guess is that two of the comments on here were written by people working on or tied to the show.
Please cast your votes, I know which two I think they are.
NG22
@Daniel-Reader: Thank you! I think many audience members are accustomed to strongly plot-driven narratives and mistake the subtlety of character-driven narratives for an error. It’s a shame, because I think there’s something really beautiful and compelling about this style of storytelling.
Great observation about the painting. In some ways, Lynn keeps his cabin as a shrine to his lover (whom we assume died from complications from AIDS). Not just the painting and the photo album, but you also get the sense they spent a lot of time there together — even if it wasn’t in that cabin. Lynn told Dom last season that he spent his 40th birthday on Russian River, doing mushrooms. You can bet his departed boyfriend was there.
And once we can see all of that, we understand so much more about Lynn, who he is, and why he can’t give Dom what he wants out of a relationship. From a combination of what we saw in the trailer for the rest of the season and what Dom said in the premiere, it’s clear that Lynn is emotionally and sexually distant. He doesn’t talk about his feelings, and he has multiple sexual partners. (That wouldn’t be a problem, except Dom clearly feels jealous and like he’s being pushed away, per the trailer. “Where do I stand?”)
Lynn is obviously still heartbroken that the love of his life was taken from him, and he’s careful to avoid ever getting that close again. Dom, meanwhile, seems to be falling for Lynn in a way he hasn’t fallen for a man before.
Sorry for the wall of text. But I could talk about this all day. The show is open to interpretation, and ideal for discussion.
barkomatic
It cracks me up that commentators who supposedly hate the show still watch every episode and then comment about it here. I thought season one was great and I enjoyed last nights premiere — though it did seem the writers tried to respond to every criticism in a single episode.
Often, when bitter gay men spew out their venom about how much they hate something it often means they are quite intrigued by the thing they feel so strongly about.
enlightenone
@Cam: “Ok, My guess is that two of the comments on here were written by people working on or tied to the show.”
Or just gay teens who lack the ability to be as discerning as some of us are given life experiences, maturity, and social/emotional intelligence!
NG22
@Cam: LOL. I love that you think I’m a plant from HBO or “Looking.” I can totally understand why you’d say that. But it is not true. I live in New York. I’ve never been to California. I’m starting grad school this fall. I have TV experience, but professionally, I have nothing to do with the broadcast.
But I so, so, so wish I *did* work at “Looking.” If either of the handsome EPs — Michael or Andrew — are reading this, call me. I’ll be your writers’ assistant next season. I’ll be a PA. I don’t care. I’m that passionate about the program.
Is it really that hard to believe someone could like this show? Scratch that, I love it.
NG22
@enlightenone: You don’t like this show. But that doesn’t make you any wiser than those who make it or those who love it. Just because it doesn’t reflect your own perspective, values, and experiences doesn’t mean it’s irrelevant or wrong.
Cam
@barkomatic: said… “Often, when bitter gay men spew out their venom about how much they hate something it often means they are quite intrigued by the thing they feel so strongly about.
______________________________________
Often when people attack anybody who disagrees with them as “Bitter” it’s because they can’t understand that in the world there are differing opinions and that somebody can have nuanced likes and dislikes about something. Or, you know, maybe you’re just bitter.
enlightenone
@NG22: “You don’t like this show. But that doesn’t make you any wiser than those who make it or those who love it. Just because it doesn’t reflect your own perspective, values, and experiences doesn’t mean it’s irrelevant or wrong.”
Nothing to do with being “wiser.” Didn’t say it is irrelevant or wrong. You can’t seem to see beyond your life experiences, level of maturity, and social/emotional intelligence which makes it “engrossing, contemplative, thoughtful, warm, hot, and beautifully-filmed. Fall in love with it over and over again! Keep “binge-watching” it brings you much…
Flaneur
Why is the color palette of this show so drab? Not to deal in stereotypes, but these are gay men! Don’t any of the characters have anything colorful or cool or even sleek and black to wear? (Watched the episode after dinner last night in my hotel in San Francisco.)
dylandog421
I am absolutely in love with this show but it took more than a few episodes to pull me in. It’s a very subtle character study and had a slow build the first season but I think that’s why I really enjoy each character and their relationships with each other. This was a great episode and the directing and camera work were amazing especially the dance floor scene in the woods. The music and flow of the scene gave one a sense of being on Molly as best as it could. This is not boring to me at all. I’m in my early 40’s and lived during the times of strong community pride. That sense of community is dissolving along with gay bars and gaybourhoods so maybe that’s why I connect with the show. It reminds me of how gay life used to be
Blackceo
Not impressed with the season premiere. The way it ended last season I was hoping it was going to be good given i think the show ended stronger than it started in season 1. Still gonna watch tho cuz and yes if I don’t love it I’m going to say so. I don’t get this kerfuffle at those who comment that they don’t like it. If u think the show is great whoopty damn do for u. Glad u enjoying it. Some of us still aren’t sold.
korzo
I dont understand why some you guys have such a huge disgust of Looking. It is just a TV show.
I live in Prague, Czech Rep. I have never been in States or SF, maybe I have different point of view. What I like on this TV show is that gay guys are shown without the “Hollywood” cliche. Life in SF seems to be interesting, characters have own real life issues which are believable. I would sort it out in a different way in my life but I dont hate them for that.
Maybe it needs to have more controversy. They are too nice to each other which seems unreal to me but maybe it will come…
nemesis9
I wonder how many articles about “Looking” Queerty can run at once?
Aussiemate
I really don’t get why people don’t like this show. I love it and it is the only show of its kind.
What do people want to happen? The show to get canceled so we can all watch the family orientated programs ?
Think about all the generations that has a enormous gap between queer as folk and looking. At least for the young ones we now have looking.
And by the way of you don’t like it. Go back to your porn perhaps that can related to you more.
MarionPaige
Take a look at the old movie “Parting Glances”, I think you will see that what Looking seems to be trying for is not so revolutionary. The casual dialogue in Looking about “A House in Virginia” would have been praised as being profoundly underplayed were this 1986 (when Parting Glances did something similar).
Looking’s Season Two premier is like the typical prelude to a horror movie. You have this silly diposable banter between characters you don’t care about (and aren’t invested in) right before they are all killed by some masked psycho or eaten by zombies. The problem therefore with Looking is that it is ALL PRELUDE and no zombies.
Consider when Jonathan Groff’s was at that party in the woods at night and that guy leaned in and kissed Groff. If instead of a kiss the guy had bitten a chunck of flesh out of Groff’s neck, it would have been a much more talked about moment. And then, that Fag Hag could stumple and crawl her way back to San Francisco and infect the whole city with the Zombie Virus. People would then be saying stuff like “I HAVE A HOUSE IN VIRGINIA AND ZURICH”
Really, there was way too much pressure put on that actress in the premier to be the ever so witty Hag.