American Idol Says Goodbye to … a Gay?

We won’t spoil the fun, but you do know one thing: Two fellas and two ladies left American Idol tonight. Who will we miss the most, for all the wrong reasons? Don’t click if you don’t want the spoiler.

Along with Luke Menard, America sent Danny Noriega home. When we asked you at the start of Idol, when the Top 20 was solidified, Danny received 32 percent of the “definitely gay” vote. Too bad he was outshined by all the other contestants. Yes, even Chikezie.

No worries, though: Cutie David Archuleta remains! We even bring you his performance this week on the next page.