Should Gerard Butler Be Running Around Telling Cucumber Sex Jokes?

Whether you believe Gerard Butler’s probably-fake interview where he acknowledges to be less-than-straight, you’ll certainly have an opinion about him telling gay sex jokes. Supposedly, the cucumber punchline he recites above is how he scored his The Ugly Truth role. Us? We’re not exactly offended by it (we love gay sex jokes), but confused: It’s a bad joke, and it shouldn’t get anyone a film gig. Then again, if Butler has experienced, uh, butt stuff, does he get permission to tell the joke?