From A Room With A View to Howards End, most of the films from Merchant Ivory—a production studio founded by namesake writer-director James Ivory and producer Ismail Merchant—fall into a specific milieu: Handsomely made costume dramas adapted from works of literature.
Because of that “a Merchant Ivory production” gradually—and unfairly—became synonymous with “boring” in the public eye. Even when their films were financially successful or won Oscars, they weren’t necessarily thought of as cool.
Sure, they weren’t action-packed blockbusters, but together Merchant and Ivory made some of the most achingly romantic movies ever. And, hey, we’re never going to call a movie that features three unclothed men playfully wrestling in a pond boring (shout-out to A Room With A View).
Your dose of fabulosi-TEA
Subscribe to our newsletter for your front-row seat to all things entertainment with a sprinkle of everything else queer.
And that’s to say nothing of Maurice, their controversial 1987 gay romance which arrived during the surge of the AIDS epidemic and a new wave of homophobia, boldly pushing the conversation forward for LGBTQ+ representation on screen.
Related:
Still swooning over ‘Lady Chatterly’s Lover’? Don’t miss this gay period romance that changed the game
Celebrating its 35th anniversary this year, ‘Maurice’ was groundbreaking for daring to depict gay romance without the tragedy.
Reputation aside, James Ivory and Ishmail Merchant were, in many ways, trailblazers. And what’s more: They were in love.
The pair first met at a screening of one of Ivory’s documentaries in 1959 and quickly hit it off. Within two years, they would launch their production company, thus beginning a professional and romantic partnership that would last 45 years, until Merchant’s death in 2005.
Though their relationship was something of an open secret among their many frequent collaborators, neither of the men spoke publicly about it, or their sexuality (which of course became especially difficult while making and promoting Maurice).
More than a decade after Merchant’s death, Ivory opened up about the reasons for their secrecy in an interview with The Guardian: “You have to remember that Ismail was an Indian citizen living in Bombay, with a deeply conservative Muslim family there. It’s not the sort of thing he was going to broadcast. Since we were so close and lived most of our lives together, I wasn’t about to undermine him.”
Two people from different worlds, coming together to make beautiful art, all while hiding their love affair from the world? Why, that almost sounds like the plot of a Merchant Ivory movie itself!
Documentarian Stephen Soucy certainly saw their story as one worth telling, thus inspiring Merchant Ivory, a new film looking back at the history of their partnership, on screen and off, and the legacy they’ll leave behind.
Told through clips of their gorgeous features, archival footage, and interviews with the stars whose lives they changed (everyone from Emma Thompson to Hugh Grant to Helena Bonham Carter), the doc received a warm reception at its U.K. premiere at the BFI Flare LGBTQ+ Film Festival earlier this month.
Next, Merchant Ivory will take a bow at the Miami Film Festival on April 13, and has be acquired by Cohen Media Group for a planned theatrical release in the U.S. later this year (dates TBA).
You can watch the trailer for the film below:
Related:
inbama
A beautiful legacy.
Paulie P
A Room With a View.. beautifully filmed, cast and Julian Sands, well, naked.
Jim
kept secret for 44 years???
Give me a break. I knew when they were Oscar darlings (deservedly so).
Apparently Cameron isn’t very observant
Having said that wish we had more movies like theirs.
inbama
Reaching the age where times you lived through become history as understood a younger generation is a constantly jarring experience.
Fahd
That it was a secret was a secret to me.
dbmcvey
I think, certainly, bye the time “Room With A View” became a huge hit they were open about it.
dbmcvey
*by
ShaverC
Only this site would claim people thought these movies were “boring”.
dbmcvey
You really don’t know what you’re talking about. There were a lot of people, including some mainstream critics, who thought their movies were slow moving and, indeed, boring. I never agreed with them of course, but they were there.
There was a mini “making of” documentary on a John Carpenter film, I think “Vampires” where the cast went out of their way to put down Merchant Ivory movies.
PoetDaddy
Yes, that “boring” comment pissed me off, too. Sadly there are a lot of people who think anything on film that’s slower than a car chase is “boring.”
Goosecurls
If you’re looking for LGBTQ representation in a Merchant Ivory film, check out “The Bostonians”. Granted the focus is not all that positive. Olive Chancellor is clearly a repressed lesbian. In the book she comes off as a predator. In the film, due to Vanessa Redgrave’s portrayal, Olive is more sympathetic.
dbmcvey
Great movie!
dbmcvey
Great filmmakers! I remember seeing “Room With A View” in the theater and being blown away. It ran at a theater in SLC for years!
After seeing it I looked up a lot of their earlier films which are all really good and should be watched! Including “Savages,” “Shakespeare Wallah,” “Roseland,” and “Jane Austen in Manhattan.”
TDurden
Maurice is one of my favorite films, it introduced me to my life-long crush, Rupert Graves.
Look forward to this documentary.
bachy
My favorite film I think ever. If you haven’t yet seen it, check out the YouTube interview entitled “Hugh Grant and James Wilby on Maurice, Merchant Ivory’s gay love story | BFI Flare” for the leading actors’ look back on their filming experience.
gregg2010
What? Their relationship was not at all hidden or a secret. They were out when they filmed “The Bostonians.”
marshal phillips
Those films were never “boring” to me. Can anyone cite a specific critic’s claim that they were “boring”?
PoetDaddy
I interviewed them both for an article I wrote about their frequent screenwriter, Ruth Prawer Jhabvala, in the early ’90s for the weekend magazine of the “Los Angeles Times,” and they were quite frank about their relationship by then.
bachy
As far as I’m concerned, Merchant/Ivory hit upon the ultimate filmmaking formula. Have loved all their wonderful romantic films.
inbama
A hot Italian coachman takes the tourists to the countryside outside Florence.
As Charlotte Bartlett (Maggie Smith) and Eleanor Lavish (Judi Dench) chat and snack on freshly-picked fruit, young Lucy Honeychurch (Helena Bonham Carter) wanders off toward dashing George Emerson (Julian Sands) who is standing in a field of tall grass dotted with orange poppies. Seeing her, George runs to her and they share a passionate kiss while gloriously voiced Dame Kiri Te Kanawa sings “Chi il bel sogno di Doretta” from Puccini’s “La Rondine” in the background.
And then, on cue, a thunderstorm.
—
No gay characters, no flesh, and yet one of the most perfect gay romantic fantasies ever filmed.
KyleMichelSullivan
Truly an elegant moment.
Rank Amateur
I never knew that Merchant Ivory films were considered boring. I’ve watched their movies multiple times and wish there were more.
SFMike
Now we live in a time where room with a view would have to have one or more of the main leads be black to make the production “appeal to a modern audience” that has no clue about actual history or literature. I’m so glad we have their now classic works.
MaineBear
Hardly a secret. I worked with them as a film finance banker and have a credit on their “Heights” picture. Ishmail dealt with me mostly as he handled the business aspect – what a charmer! Such an intelligent and lovely man. Died too young. He was very interested in my love life and my “type”. Wish I could have gotten to know them better personally
KyleMichelSullivan
They made some lovely films, and consider — they started out when being gay was illegal. In 1967, the Sexual Offenses Act was passed to decriminalize private homosexual acts between men who were 21 or older. But it also imposed harsher penalties on “public offenses.” The law didn’t get changed in Scotland till 1980, while Northern Ireland was 1982.
Now keep in mind, anti-sodomy laws are still on the books in states like Texas, despite Obergefell. Cops still arrest men using those laws; the DAs usually just refuse to prosecute, but now the gay guys have an arrest record over something that’s been declared legal. And right wing Christo-fascists are still out to reverse that ruling.
GayEGO
My husband and I met on March 4th, 1962 in Boston, MA and got married on June 10th, 2004 in Cambridge, MA. Now I am a widower after my husband passed away on June 17th, 2019 in Worcester, we were together 57 years! At least I can say we lived the American Dream!