a gay old time

Why watching 1973’s ‘Jesus Christ Superstar’ is the gayest way to celebrate Easter weekend

By · 12 comments
Image Credit: ‘Jesus Christ Superstar,’ Universal Pictures

Welcome back to our queer film retrospective, “A Gay Old Time.” In a very special Easter edition of the column, we’re revisiting the campy 1973 adaptation of the rock musical Jesus Christ Superstar.

The canon for “queer movies about Easter” isn’t exactly the most robust one. Because of its close and obvious link with Christianity and Catholicism (religions that obscure us at best and actively fight against us at worst), not many films depict the story of Jesus’ death and resurrection through an explicit queer lens—even if there are many works of religious film with heavy homoerotic subtext (see our previous column on Derek Jarman’s Sebastiane, for example).

However, this week we take a turn into queer-adjacent territory with the film adaptation of one of the most famous shows in musical theater history, Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice’s Jesus Christ Superstar.

It’s as close to a queer interpretation of Jesus’ last days as we’re probably ever going to get, and the film staging (as well as some of the character dynamics) definitely speak directly into the interests of our community.

The Set-Up

Jesus Christ Superstar was conceived first as a concept album by Lloyd Webber and Rice (who did the music and lyrics, respectively) in 1970, before being performed for the first time on Broadway a year later.

The show is a sung-through rock opera based on the Gospel’s recounting of the days leading to the death and resurrection of Jesus. It follows the massive societal movement that he built with his followers, the fear that his power put on the roman army, his relationship with his apostles (in particular Judas, who believes he has lost his way, and the Mary Magdalene’s infatuation with him), and his subsequent betrayal and crucifixion.

This telling of a widely known tale is more concerned with Jesus as a flawed, human figure over anything divine. He’s portrayed as a cultural juggernaut, blindly adored and followed everywhere by the masses (a sandal-wearing Harry Styles, if you may), who is starting to lose faith and confidence in his own teachings as they get more and more popular.

The main tension exists between him and Judas (“his right hand man from the beginning”), who feels left behind as Jesus’ notoriety rises, and believes he has given up his beliefs for fame. 

Ever since its inception, the show embedded the biblical story with present-day satire, lingo, and many anachronisms that made it feel much more current. It’s often performed with many artistic and creative liberties that make it less a period piece adaptation and more a theatrical experience—using the Passion of Christ as a conduit to explore fanaticism, cultural storytelling, and theatricality.

Matinee Messiah

Image Credit: ‘Jesus Christ Superstar,’ Universal Pictures

The show became an indisputable hit upon its premiere, with a movie adaptation made only two years after. And the film is no exception to its core artistic statement.

Directed by the legendary Norman Jewison (who gave us other queer-adjacent classics such as Fiddler On The Roof and Moonstruck) and starring a cast of mostly unknowns or stage performers (Ted Neely as Jesus, Carl Anderson as Judas, and Yvonne Elliman as Mary Magdalene, to name a few), the film elevates the theatricality of the stage production at every turn, making it one of the “most” movie musicals ever put on screen.

The film is narratively framed as a theater troupe putting on a show about Jesus’ life in the middle of the desert. During the overture, which is set in the present day (the 1970s vibes in the costuming and hairstyles are off the wall), a bus full of actors, performers, and crew members arrive at some ancient ruins to put on a show for us. Everything afterwards is viewed through the lens of a show within a movie, and the film takes that opportunity to let go of the restraints that a “period movie” would have, and bring heightened showmanship and spectacle to every number in a way that feels both authentic and revolutionary; just like the stage show.

Related:

Praise him: 10 times the movies turned biblical figures into sex symbols

Forgive us, father, for we have sinned.

Sing It, Jesus!

We of course get the staples of large-scale movie musicals like complex choreography (here done in scaffolding in the middle of the desert), emotional ballads (Jesus questioning God about why he has to die in “This Jesus Must Die” or Mary Magdalene quietly confessing her love in “I Don’t Know How To Love Him”), and a throw-everything-at-the-wall finale number (a choir dressed head to toe in disco spandex gospel outfits).

But Jewinson takes it one step further and infuses the movie with a uniquely cinematic flair that elevates it beyond just a filmed version of the stage show: gigantic sets and locations that truly convey the sense of grandeur of the story, freeze frames and close ups that show us emotions the way only a camera could, and an ongoing sense of spectacle that make you want to watch this in the biggest screen possible.

Tender Moments

Image Credit: ‘Jesus Christ Superstar,’ Universal Pictures

Apart from the sheer pageantry that we tend to gravitate towards, there are some smaller elements that may also resonate with our community. Although it’s never explicitly romantic or sexual (the musical wouldn’t go that far), there is a lot of open love between Jesus and Judas. They have a long-lasting relationship that has been broken and has left both parties incredibly hurt.

The film stages the two characters interacting with plenty of physical touch that definitely reads as homoerotic. Similarly, Mary Magdalene’s heartbreaking signature ballad, the aforementioned “I Don’t Know How To Love Him” will resonate vividly with anyone that has experienced unrequited love of any kind, a topic that we tend to be well-versed at.

The Gayest Easter Tradition

Image Credit: ‘Jesus Christ Superstar,’ Universal Pictures

Jesus Christ Superstar is an incredibly fun, stylish and often silly ride that feels like a worthy extension of one of the most unusual pieces of theater to come out from that time.

Its ambition makes you wish that studios and audiences took risks as big as this with musicals nowadays (both on screen and on stage), and proves that no matter the subject matter, there is always a way to bring people on board if you just add enough sparkle. A yearly Easter watch party of this is a tradition that this Jesus would proudly approve of.

Jesus Christ Superstar is currently streaming on Peacock, and available for digital rental/purchase via AppleTV, Amazon Prime Video, Google Play, Vudu, and YouTube TV.

Related:

People are praising this VERY revealing portrait of a Biblical ‘Adam and Steve’ 

Can we tempt you?

Don't forget to share:

Help make sure LGBTQ+ stories are being told...

We can't rely on mainstream media to tell our stories. That's why we don't lock Queerty articles behind a paywall. Will you support our mission with a contribution today?

Once Monthly Annually

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated