Virginia Governor Glenn Youngkin’s transphobic rhetoric started blowing in the wind last week under the slightest questioning by an actual transgender person.
During a CNN Town Hall on Thursday, the anti-LGBTQ+ governor’s policies limiting the rights of transgender students were called into question by a student named Niko to his face.
“Your transgender policies require students play on the sports teams and use the restrooms that correspond with their sex assigned at birth,” the teen says.
“Look at me. I am a transgender man. Do you really think the girls in my high school would feel comfortable sharing a restroom with me?”
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
Glenn’s answer certainly was a collection of words:
Glenn starts by thanking Niko for his involvement in “this important discussion” before immediately side-stepping the question to ramble a bit on the supposed parental rights that his legislation hides behind.
“I believe, first, when parents are engaged with their children, then you can make good decisions together,” he says.
In addition to discriminating against trans students in sports and restrooms, the policies the governor put into effect last fall require parental approval for a student to use any pronouns or names other than what’s listed in their official record.
Rather than saying whether Niko, a boy, should be using the men’s or women’s bathroom at school, Glenn just says all schools need to make “extra bathrooms”.
“There are lots of students involved in this decision, and what’s most important is that we try very hard to accommodate students,” he equivocates. “That’s why I have said many, many times we just need extra bathrooms in schools. We need general neutral bathrooms so people can use a bathroom that they in fact are comfortable with.”
This might sound progressive to anyone not reading between the lines at the governor pointedly ignoring that Niko is comfortable using the men’s restroom and doesn’t require alternative accommodations.
Related:
Glenn goes on to address the point of trans students in sports, once again ignoring the reality or the transmasculine students in front of him to solely focus on transfeminine student athletes.
“I don’t think it’s controversial,” he states. “I don’t think that biological boys should be playing sports with biological girls… It’s just not fair.”
In a statement released by the Human Rights Campaign following the night’s Town Hall, Campaign Director Geoff Wetrosky spoke out against Glenn’s hypocritical “parental rights” platform.
“Tonight, Glenn Youngkin once again claimed that he believes that ‘parents matter,’” Wetrosky states. “In reality he only cares about some parents. He does not care about parents of LGBTQ+ – particularly transgender – students, who have been consistently under attack in Virginia and across the country.”
Wetrosky continues, “He said that there is no room for bullying or harassment in Virginia’s schools, but his own policies only further marginalize and isolate transgender students, creating more stigma and more discrimination against an already vulnerable population. His extremist, anti-LGBTQ+ positions should have no place in Virginia, or this country.”
Related:
Amid the wave of anti-LGBTQ bills sweeping the nation, this state just did something amazing for queer people
The law finally passed after about 40 years of stonewalling from Republicans.
abfab
This man has a brain the size of a fruit fly.
Kangol2
A gnat. A smashed one.
kassymellen
This dud has a brain the size of an atom.. and would need a microscope to find it..
LumpyPillows
6th grade taunts. While I agree Gov. Youngkin is biased and his attempts at legislation are wrong, it is a bit embarrassing that this is what you bring to the discussion.
dbmcvey
@LumpyPillows
Because your usual anti-trans stuff is better?
LumpyPillows
LOL, troll.
abfab
He is not a troll.
inbama
There is so much BS on both sides on every aspect of this subject.
Generally speaking, transmen are a threat to no one. When it comes to male sports, they face all the same disadvantages that biological women face when competing with a transwoman who’s gone through a male puberty. This is why there’s no public outcry about transmen.
As for rape – yes, there are convicted transgender rapists, but they’re transwomen and not transmen. This is why the feminists we trash as “terfs” campaign against transferring intact transwomen who’ve raped or murdered women into female prisons.
Biology isn’t fair – which makes it impossible to find a sim[le solution that’s fair to everyone.
abfab
Before I pose a question to you, are you sure about everything you just wrote?
LumpyPillows
Sound and rational points. What we are now seeing is the backlash to the extreme left wing demands from the trans anarchists I was warning about. They have screwed us all. Makes me wonder how much of this nonsense came out of a right wing or Russian think tank/propaganda centers. I’m confident Jeffrey Marsh is getting dirty anti-LGBT money from somewhere…if not, he should be.
Eternal.Cowboy
@afab
Inbama regularly makes false statements about transpeople, why would this be any different?
LumpyPillows
P.S. there are studies out that show trans women commit crime and rape at essentially the same percentage as men.
You can cosmetically change a man into a woman, but there are some things you just can’t change. That is exactly what you people don’t get. You defend this stuff in the same blind allegiance as the right does with Trump. The similarities are striking. You refuse to ever admit anything is wrong. To our demise.
Eternal.Cowboy
@Lumpuy
Cite your source.
LumpyPillows
Google is your friend. You can educate yourself. Nice study in the UK. Will take seconds to find it.
Eternal.Cowboy
So, you can’t cite your source…. tell us again about about detailed and thoughtful you posts are we need a laugh.
LumpyPillows
Did you even bother to look? UK Parliament study. Pops right up when you search on transgender crime.
dbmcvey
Inbama and LumpyPillows anti-trans histories should be noted.
Dr Sarah
I’ve found people often talk about the supposed problems of trans rights as though they somehow *originated* with the idea of trans rights instead of being pre-existing problems. With regard to the ‘which prison do we put this person in?’ issue, there have always been women who committed murder or sexual assault, so this isn’t a new question that just came up with greater recognition of trans people. As I understand it, they’re kept separately from other prisoners and/or kept in male prisons, and that’s normal regardless of whether they’re cis or trans.
LumpyPillows
Still waiting for you to bring evidence I’m anti trans. Waiting…Waiting…Waiting. Just saying a thing does not make it so.
If I were truly anti-trans, why would I just not say so? This is the typical troll behavior – accuse anyone who has a different perspective a transphobe. It’s lazy. It supports the right’s attacks on the vindictive and nasty left wing bullies. I know you’re upset that I’ve rubbed your nose in it before. You just can’t seem to grow up and move on. Limited social skills…tsk, tsk.
Trans people are under fire in the red states because people like you are politically stupid. Not me. You. You, my dear, are the trans enemy, not me.
DBMC
Lumpers, Lumpy, Lumpon,
Really? You constantly go on screeds where you bring in the tiny number of trans people who detransitioned, despite the fact that they are being used by anti-gay propagandists to throw doubt on transgender people without doing any research about their ties and ignoring the vast majority who are happy about transitioning. Please don’t try to pretend you’re not advancing anti-trans sentiment.
LumpyPillows
Another fail. Try again. My concerns are legitimate and personal. Because other people agree with some of my points and reach other conclusions is not my fault. My concerns are real. You know they are real. You flippantly disregard the harm done to people by saying their are irrelevant. Cruel, but you are cruel. All I want is better protocols for verifying gender dysmorphia before changing children’s bodies. Why do you hate that? I mean, I continue to try and communicate with you and the other trolls and all you want to do is be dicks.
Everything you type is irrelevant, made up, unsubstantiated and hysterical. I find your lack of concern for the proper medical care of children to be scary. You don’t even seem concerned. You are the reason there is backlash, not me. The laws they are passing are in response to you. Take some responsibility for your rhetoric and its backlash. I know you won’t.
abfab
Troll defined.
I mean, I continue to try and communicate with you and the other trolls and all you want to do is be dicks.
LumpyPillows
I’m reasonably confident he will get picked last for the men’s rugby team. Whereas any trans woman is getting picked first for the women’s rugby team. Reality.
abfab
Reasonably confident? How convicing. You’re cruel. You’re a bully, and you’re obnoxious. Stop.
LumpyPillows
Really? Explain.
Eternal.Cowboy
What clarification is needed, abfab nailed it. You are consistently an asshole.
Neoprene
Except Dylan Mulvaney. He gets picked last for either team.
LumpyPillows
Nah, cow, I usually write detailed thoughts about a topic that you do not agree with. You, are the one who insults and is an asshole. Rarely an insightful thought in your head.
This fellow is a woman underneath…small, un menacing, not threat to women. You do get the point I was making? Probably not.
Abby, on the other hand, just really sems to always be high, but at leas he usually isn’t rude, like you.
Eternal.Cowboy
“I usually write detailed thoughts about a topic ”
Wait, you posts are detailed thoughts? That is a sad state of affairs as they lack any sort of detail. The certainty count as thoughts … not not particularly well informed thoughts.
“This fellow is a woman underneath…small, un menacing, not threat to women. You do get the point I was making? Probably not.”
I understand the point you are making, I also get that your feelings about trans women are deeply rooted in your misogyny. Most transphobia is just misogyny repackaged.
But by all means, continue to detail your thoughtful bigotry.
LumpyPillows
Elaborate one that…I am not transphobic. What have I ever written that was transphobic? It is a narrative you want because it fits the battle you want to fight. It is what the toxic left does, it labels any disagreement transphobic. It is why there is such backlash now. Backlash people like you invited. Women have turned on the trans movement. If you were only more honest, it might be an interesting discussion.
Trans people deserve human rights, health care, jobs, housing, respect and safety. I have always said this. What a trans woman is not is a woman. That is my disagreement. You can disagree, but you really should respect my position and not pervert it into something else. I am not transphobic, but I do respect women’s rights and spaces. You don’t. I could call you a misogynist…if I played the game like you do – cheaply and with some perverse desire to be vindictive – another common trait with the rest of the far left extremists.
Eternal.Cowboy
“I am not transphobic”
Saying it doesn’t make it so. You regularly make transphobic comments. You regularly misgender people and tell them they are a fad and don’t exist. You are transphobic, you obviously know you are wrong, it’s why you fight against being called transphobic.
“Women have turned on the trans movement.”
Not true. Americans at large support trans rights, Per Gallup 66% of the U.S population supports trans rights, 76% of women do. Republicans are the only group that doesn’t crack the 55% mark, the second lowest demographic is people 65 of oder. ….. Remember enthusiasm for the red wave?
Lastly, your comments about women in this thread date you, They are antiquated stereotypes, of course you don’t see yourself as misogynist you see your views as normal. They were what you were taught. Society has progressed, you haven’t.
“You can disagree, but you really should respect my position’
I have no respect for bigotry. It only deserves condemnation.
LumpyPillows
Go find one transphobic comment. I’ll wait.
You act just like a Trump supporter – labeling everyone who disagrees as an enemy. You throw around the transphobe barb with such disregard for what an actually transphobe is that you debase it. I neither hate nor fear trans people.
Your stats are dated, sweetie. Look especially to the UK, where the backlash has been swift and strong in the last few months. You really think women like being called birthing people? You really think they like be called CIS women? You really think they like the term TERF? You really think they are happy with trans women in their sports? Have you been listening to women lately or ever? I have. It’s not pretty. They went from not paying attention to really paying attention because they are mad.
Lastly, exactly what is it that I have said that you think is bigoted? I mean you must think of me that way to justify why you are always so nasty. You can disagree with me, I’m not always right, but what exactly have I said that qualifies as bigoted? I’m curious.
Why don’t you copy and paste things like this “Trans people deserve human rights, health care, jobs, housing, respect and safety.” You do like to cut and paste, selectively. Do you not read them? Does it not sink in because it does not fit your narrative that I am the boogey man? Or is it just too difficult to understand the nuance of my position? Your hate is ugly. It is what is wrong with the left and the right. You, my dear, are part of the problem.
Dr Sarah
Depends on things like whether they’ve been through male or female puberty and what they’re getting by way of hormone treatment.
dbmcvey
@LumpyPillows
You regularly site anti-trans propaganda especially using the highly criticized “detransitioned” people who are being used by anti-LGBT groups.
LumpyPillows
What anti-trans propaganda do I cite? Entertain me. Yes, there are a growing number of people who have or want to de-transition. Do you deny it? It’s just a fact. How many ruined bodies will it take for you to care?
You do not care that people have been hurt. It does not fit your politics to care. That makes you the propagandist.
Seriously, if you can’t grow up and stop being so nasty and agree to discuss real issue without getting hysterical, I’m not going to waste my time.
abfab
Lumpy (how descriptive)
I don’t need defending. You’re the last person (troll) that I would want in my corner.
abfab
And yes, LP I’m always high (if you insist) that is until I read your bullshit. Buzzkill City! You sound exhausted and out of steam. Your grammar and spelling have become atrocious.
GreekKeys
“I am a woman”
Saying it doesn’t make it so.
Neoprene
She’s a very cute boy.
DBMC
Wow Neoprene! That was the funniest joke of 1988!
LumpyPillows
He is cute. I find a lot of trans men to be attractive. They do tend to be quite short for some reason.
Neoprene
Wow Lumpy! That was the funniest joke of 1989!
LumpyPillows
Wasn’t really meant to be funny. Just my reality.
James
YOUNGKIN IS A NAZI MORON.
Chaucer
Glenn Youngkin is a wolf in sheep’s clothing. He’s a controlling arch-conservative with fanatical religious beliefs who lies when he campaigns. Nobody should believe anything he says on the campaign trail. He completely snowed a lot of Virginians–especially women in NOVA. And, of course, all of the uneducated and uninformed Fox “News” watchers voted for him. He’s not to be trusted.
GreekKeys
Firstly, “Niko” still looks like a woman. Second, no one is comfortable with a cross-dressing person in either bathroom. Except, of course, the the highly evolved readers of Queerty, who are lightyears ahead of the rest of the unenlightened. Now, Niko, as a reasonable facsimile of a dude, can live as the heterosexual she’s always dreamed of being. Because, really, who’d want to be gay now? They’re the enemy.