Beautiful Thing, by British writer Jonathan Harvey, remains one of the best-loved gay love stories to emerge from the 1990s. When it first premiered at the relatively small Bush Theatre in London in 1993, it proved a sensation. Theatrical gay characters before this were often coded or sidelined. When they did take center stage, the angst-ridden protagonists often led secret, depressing lives.
Sure, The Boys In The Band may have been groundbreaking for its time, but who would want to be a guest at that particular party? The arrival of AIDS in the 1980s did nothing to lighten the mood.
Romances, reservations, and more juicy behind-the-scenes details you might not know about ‘The Boys In The Band.’
By contrast, Beautiful Thing focuses on two working-class teenage boys on a south London council estate who tentatively fall in love during a summer heatwave. Yes, they struggle with their feelings and live in fear of being called “queer”. Domestic confrontations also loom large in their lives. However, Harvey adds dollops of savage humor and acerbic wit to balance out the play’s darker edges.
A West End transfer followed, and then a movie version in 1996. There have been revivals since. This new production at the Royal Theatre Stratford East marks the play’s 30th anniversary.
Offering a fresh perspective, director Anthony Simpson-Pike has cast Black actors in the lead roles, commenting, “Beautiful Thing is an iconic queer story that holds a special place in so many people’s hearts. Many people saw their own stories on stage and screen for the first time. In its 30th anniversary year, I feel excited for people who look like me to see their own stories reflected on stage, too, to feel that same stirring of recognition in this seminal piece.”
No Tea, No Shade
Fifteen-year-old Jamie (Rilwan Abiola Owokoniran) lives with his mom, Sandra (Shvorne Marks). Jamie is friends with 16-year-old neighbors Leah (Scarlett Rayner) and Ste (Joshua Asaré). Tony is a 27-year-old painter and decorator dating Sandra and is the closest thing Jamie has to a father figure.
Ste is a budding soccer player. However, that’s when he’s not hiding the bruises his ever-drinking father imparts on him. To escape his old man’s beatings, Sandra allows Ste to sleep over with Jamie. Her son hates sports and prefers The Sound of Music, but — sharing a single bed — the two boys soon find they have other interests in common.
Sandra (an excellent turn by Marks) is a domineering single mom. She berates Jamie for avoiding sports lessons, blasts Leah as a “slag” best avoided by all, and keeps a wary eye out for Ste’s welfare. She gives the weed-puffing Tony a hard time because life has taught her that men are unreliable. Her reaction to finding out her son is gay is the climax the play hurtles towards, soundtracked by a nostalgic catalog of songs by the Mamas & Papas.
This production has not been without some drama of its own. A couple of days before the scheduled press night, producers announced the actor originally cast to play Jamie had been forced to drop out for personal reasons. A replacement, Owokoniran, stepped up to the challenge of taking on the role at short notice.
The original press night was postponed to allow the actor time to make the role his own. This he does admirably, even if he and Asaré aren’t quite convincing as teenagers. But that’s a minor quibble. It remains refreshing to see the play shining a spotlight on young Black queer lives.
Let’s Have a Moment
Harvey’s script doesn’t appear to have been updated in any way. Some references, like the ’80s TV police drama Cagney & Lacey (co-starring Tyne Daly, who returns to Broadway this winter in a revival of Doubt) and ’90s British soccer players, date the piece. Most audiences won’t mind — times have changed, but the situation remains as believable as ever.
It’s the relationship between Sandra and Jamie that underpins the story. We never get to see Ste’s dad, even if he looms over the drama.
The bedroom scenes remain sweet and tender in their fumbling innocence. Jamie soothes Ste’s bruises with the aid of some Body Shop Peppermint Foot Lotion. It’s the sort of everyday detail that makes Harvey’s script so relatable.
Much of the play’s humor comes from the Mama Cass-obsessed Leah (Scarlett Rayner). Like all the characters, she simply wants her life to get better, throwing herself at men in a quest for love and matching Sandra’s barbed put-downs with her own.
Leah thinks the whole world hates her. “We despair of you. That’s different,” says Sandra toward the end, revealing how concern can quickly be confused for criticism.
The confusion between emotions weaves its way through the story. Why is something that feels natural supposed to be wrong? Why do we sometimes reject what’s good for us?
The Last Word
There’s so much queer content available to stream nowadays it’s hard to appreciate just how groundbreaking and much-needed Beautiful Thing was when it first arrived on stage, pre-dated by a handful of powerful queer playwrights, including Terrence McNally and Harvey Fierstein.
The decision to diversify the cast and emphasize the play’s relevance is not just a marketing ploy. It’s easy to forget that it remains hard for many to come out.
Disappointingly, the Saturday matinee show I attended had a few empty rows in the auditorium. That’s a crying shame. Whether you’ve seen this before or not, if you’re in the UK, I’d urge you to go and enjoy this queer classic all over again.
‘Desperate Housewives’ and ‘Melrose Place ‘alum Marcia Cross co-stars in the new play by bestselling author Tawni O’Dell.