“Howl” by Alan Ginsberg is considered to be one of the great works of American literature and a quintessential example of 1950s Beat poetry. But when 17-year-old Skylar Carson’s dad found out his daughter had been assigned to read the controversial (by 1950s standards) poem, he was outraged.
“She came home and shared it with us and, of course, as a parent the way we’ve raised our kids, I was like, there’s no way a teacher in a public school would have done this,” Brett Carson tells local news station Fox31.
Skylar is a junior at Steamboat Springs High School in Colorado. Her dad says he was never informed his daughter was going read an “explicit work” that talks about stuff like “drugs, alcohol, and c*ck and endless balls.”
“A lot of the kids, you know, were scared to say anything to their parents because it was so awkward and just weird,” he claims.
It’s unclear who else, other than his own daughter, Carson is referring to when he says “a lot of the kids.”
Because it’s not like “a lot of the kids,” especially 17-year-olds, can’t find this stuff or worse on their own. The internet offers a virtual treasure trove of pornographic material to any teenager with an imagination and an IP address.
But, evidently, Skylar isn’t like most 17-year-olds. She read the poem and was totally traumatized.
“The second we started reading the book it just went south,” she says. “It was so filled with sexual content that I wasn’t aware of and I wasn’t prepared for.”
Poor thing. Just wait until a year from now, when she turns 18 and sees her first R-rated movie.
“I’m just hoping it doesn’t happen to anyone else in the classroom,” she laments.
Now, the Carsons are suing the school for exposing their daughter to such vulgarity.
“It’s their responsibility to come to us as parents and say, hey we’re going to talk about some controversial material here,” Carson says. “If you want to opt out here’s your opt out form and we’ll give you an alternate assignment.”
They have hired religious liberty attorney Jeremy Dys, a lawyer at First Liberty Institute, one of the largest law firms “dedicated exclusively to defending and restoring religious liberty for all Americans.”
As part of the lawsuit, the Carsons are demanding every single parent be sent a letter of apology from the teacher who assigned the text and that the school require staff to undergo sensitivity training to avoid this sort of thing from happening again in the future.
“Howl” was originally published in 1956, when gay sex was still illegal in all 50 states, and was the subject of an obscenity trial in 1957, 62 years ago, though Judge Clayton W. Horn ultimately ruled that the poem was not obscene.
Joshua333
And they call gay people snowflakes… sheesh. First R rated movie at 18, what a sheltered child.
PLAYS WELL WITH OTHERS
Anyone wanna guess on how many kiddie porn files this noxious repugnant vile smcubag puke has on it’s computer???
masterwill7
You are just as bad as the right wing idiots.. It’s never a joke to accuse someone of being a child molester.
In this situation I would also have called the school and would have asked them if this was necessary for under aged kids!? It’s just not appropriate to let kids read this for a study assignment… Ok, the lawsuit is a little much…
PLAYS WELL WITH OTHERS
masterwill7:. Based on past history my comment has a significant chance of actually being a fact….
Oh and BTW piss off noxious troll..,.
gymmuscleboy
@masterwill7 Ignore that commenter – he obviously has no place calling other people trolls.
msc1208
If she is 17 she is old enough to see her first R-Rated movie now. UNDER 17 requires parent or legal guardian. Not 17 & under as most people incorrectly assume.
DuMaurier
A lawsuit is ridiculous (but very American!), but I’ll swim against the tide and say I find assigning “Howl” to students (before college, anyhow) a bad idea. And saying it’s ok because kids can find worse on their own is vapid. An eight year-old can find find bestiality porn on a computer; I don’t think that means we say, “Welp, might as well show “Amanda Does a Donkey” to the second grade kiddies!”
James
GO BACK TO YOUR CHRIXTIAN FAMILY VALUES, WHO NEEDS YOU.
KerryB
More likely that the trauma was caused by her mentally ill, reich-wing christian nut-job parents.
James
STUPID MORONIC CHRIXTIAN TRASH FAMILY JUST NOW FINDING OUT ABOUT HOWL.
djmcgamester
Howl? Really? lol
Itsonlythetruth
Most kids wouldn’t tell their parents because they would act like assholes, just like this guy. Unless this 17 year old lived under a rock I’m sure she wouldn’t have been so traumatized as she says, Dad is looking for a payday..
Jack Meoff
Any excuse to try an extort some money out of people is the way I read this.
ezwriter
Allen Ginsberg was an admitted pedophile. An actual member of NAMBLA.
Not sure how “Howl”, as important historically as it may be, manages to get assigned in a high school class given that fact. It puts people like us, who normally would never side with this father and daughter, in the position of having to defend a the work of a pedo.
Surely there are other works of beat poetry written by less problematic figures that could be assigned instead, no?
boymikefl
You can read it for free on JSTOR.org. Google Howl & look for jstor.org. I myself, don’t care.
nitejonboy
As much as I hate being a devil’s advocate, this is NOT the kind of Beat poetry to assign teenagers to read in high school. It paints us as sex crazy horndogs ( yes,I know it’s true but still ),and as said before was written by an admitted pedophile who never should have become famous in the first place. Pick another Beat poet who actually contributed something worthwhile. Don’t give the teens all of those ” Endless Balls ! ” to be traumatized by ( Oh those endless balls!!! ) when you know there are some who won’t be able to handle it. In high school they still have their parents to control them, in college the teacher has more control and can tell the student to drop the class if they don’t want to read a book assigned to them. The lawsuit is ridiculous,but the parent is in the right here sadly.