Makeup influencer and YouTuber Jeffree Star set the internet sleuths into a frenzy on the weekend. As we reported yesterday, he posted a photo of himself on a plane, holding the hands of someone he referred to as his new “NFL boo.”
“Goodbye LA, time to spend time with my #NFL boo in Wyoming 🏈” he captioned the photo, prompting Twitter users to guess the identity of the man. Star is known to own a ranch in Wyoming and often escapes there.
Related: Jeffree Star teases photo of new “NFL boo” and now everyone’s trying to guess who the mystery man is
Last night, Star followed that post up with a new photo. This one was almost a full-length shot of the mystery man. Frustratingly, the man has his back to the camera, so his identity remains unknown.
This time, Star also dropped a few more clues.
“His team didn’t make it to the #SuperBowl but he’s 6’6 and plays perfect in the bedroom 🧡”
His team didn’t make it to the #SuperBowl but he’s 6’6 and plays perfect in the bedroom 🧡 pic.twitter.com/fNKUY4MHi0
— Jeffree Star (@JeffreeStar) January 30, 2023
The only out, gay player in the NFL is Tampa Bay Buccaneers outside linebacker Carl Nassib. However, Nassib recently went Instagram official with his boyfriend, Danish swimmer Søren Dahl.
This weekend’s Superbowl is between Philadelphia Eagles and the Kansas City Chiefs, which rules out any players from those teams.
Of course, this could also just be a publicity stunt by Star and he’s not in a relationship with any NFL player. He does seem to go for tall men, though. He previously had a brief relationship with basketball player Andre Marhold.
Either way, Star’s followers threw themselves into trying to identify the guy.
everyone trying to figure out who this man is rn 😳 pic.twitter.com/v88yw06ppf
— Ray🫧 (@itsyaboyrayy) January 30, 2023
It’s not Carl guys pic.twitter.com/d8zCblnj1U
— Cody Titus (@ThisisCodyT) January 30, 2023
— kaeishaxox (@kaeishaxox) January 30, 2023
Cole Kmet pic.twitter.com/VW3pD8ouxS
— Judith (@itsjudiiiith) January 30, 2023
It’s Rick Wagner. The only player that is white, 6’6, has brown hair, active NFL player and didn’t make it to the Super Bowl. Same body type. You’re welcome
— OBZRVR (@Korbin_Mass) January 30, 2023
it’s this dude the ears match pic.twitter.com/qbK1PSfkDV
— baylor (@literalytheking) January 30, 2023
“Hey Siri, who’s 6’6” in the NFL and didn’t make it to the SuperBowl?” pic.twitter.com/uW4bybOv1Z
— Kristen Herrera (@kristenerikat) January 30, 2023
Can someone tell me who it is once they find out. Don’t feel like doing all that research
— ᱬ A L E X ❤️🔥 (@_hoekage_23) January 30, 2023
Related: Jeffree Star launches make-up in shades of ‘top,’ ‘bottom’ and ‘glory hole’
Besides guessing the identity of the mystery man, others also wanted to talk about, well, other things in the photo.
I know everyone is trying to figure out who your man is but babe why do you have a silencer on the counter lol
— Collier Fernekes 🦃🍂 (@collierfernekes) January 31, 2023
Nonchalant pistol on the counter
— Skermz (@YungSkermz) January 31, 2023
@b__ried I have seen this 8 times throughout the course of the day and I just now saw the gun
— nate whalez (@whalez) January 31, 2023
RIGay
…and doing his part to protect the environment by using a private jet.
When I hear “influencer” as the primary adjective; it immediately translates to “douche bag”.
Hard pass on caring.
inbama
She looks less human than a blow-up doll.
still_onthemark
Jeffree and Melania must go to the same… robot mechanic?
Dick Gozinia
Totally agree. YAWN!
Toofie
He’s just a total mess.
Manray
I find Jeffree about as appealing as a cadaver with Rigor mortis.
cc423
What a pathetic last ditch gasp for relevancy
ZzBomb
Pretty much all the information is there to figure this out, interwebs and people with too much time on their hands.
But this is a pretty sad attention seeking ploy. Like what’s the point? Potentially outting a guy who does not seem ready by childishly dropping tid-bits here and there for the internet to sleuth out? Showing off to their haters that they can get a supposed NFL player, which isn’t that big of a deal anyway?
Idk, but this isn’t how an adult in a real loving relationship behaves.
bachy
Considering the photo, above, of Jeffree Star, I would never in a million years imagine he would be seeking a “real, loving, adult relationship.”
Dude be a freaky lookin’ for his deaky.
bachy
Unrelated, but can you believe how much some of these tall NFL players weigh???
I had no idea.
Paulie P
shouldn’t be too hard to spot them in Wyoming.. look for a 6’6 guy and a has been in a wig.
Manray
I see the hand holding pic and think “when Nosferatu is holding your hand”
bachy
@Manray: LOL
Tad
COULD BE….a publicity stunt?!? What is there for someone like him? His whole adult life has been aiming at this moment when he has thousands of people guessing who might be invading his snatch. What a non-story from a Kardashian wanna-be.
hotshot70
This is where I get to use this phrase.
IDGAFOS
SFMike
Why would anyone want to be identified as sleeping with Jeffree Star. The pictures of the “influencer” are less than appealing.
Sotzume
Glad to know a hot NFL player is into elderly old gay men…
Manray
Oh burn…..Jeffree does have that “creepy weird spinster aunt,” thing going on.
The tattoos, the pink hair, she just creeps me out.
Kangol2
Star is only 37, so that was a very harsh read!
SDR94103
bs
phillycap
He has achieved his goals. Everyone is talking about this trifling ho.
SoloMcDaniel
If it’s even true, he never said the guy played in the NFL. Just said “my NFL boo”. Dude could work in the office of an NFL team. however I think it’s totally some publicity stunt to get exposure on sites like Queerty.
Velvetalex
He’s sleeping with Jeff for the $$$.
nm4047
Well he’s white (assuming it’s his hand being held). That should eliminate quite a few of the NFL players. Hair colour also another feature that would eliminate another large number.
Kangol2
70% of them, though Jeffree Star’s last high profile relationship was with Andre Marhold. (For some reason my comment about this, which wasn’t problematic in the least, seems to have disappeared.) At any rate, whatever floats Star’s and his new man’s boats!
JOEY NYC
who cares she’s disgusting clearly seeking attention to try and be relevant . that football player needs his head examined if he’s having sex with that awful thing . yuck!
Manray
Lol. It’s true.
If your weird auntie became a vampire….
Peter
Nothing looks better behind a diamond necklace than some hideous tattoos. Smart. So easy to pick out of a lineup.
Tacapollo
Never heard of Jeffree before and I don’t think I’ve missed out on anything. Sleeping with that would be a horror show and, frankly, makes me question the tastes and mental facilities of anyone that would sleep with him. Either way tho, I really could care less.
SparkyMICH
Everyone seems to be under the impression that NFL stands for National Football League — it could stand for something completely different and he’s using the comment about the superbowl as a misdirect. He doesn’t actually say he plays football. No one here made it to the superbowl either.
MrMichaelJ
There are so many holes in this story with main one being Starr hooking up with an NFL player
randy_sanchez
Pray tell, why is this relevant?
scotty
the kicker…it’s gonna be the kicker. that guy from the vikings maybe