A woman terrified that her self-labeled bisexual boyfriend might actually turn out to be gay has sought advice from a therapist writing in The Atlantic. In short, the therapist’s advice had a high dose of tough love.
“I’m worried because (a) he’s never been with a man before and being with me means he won’t get that experience (assuming he doesn’t cheat) and (b) he comes from an extremely religious family in the South who would likely not be able to accept his homosexuality (or even bisexuality),” the woman writes. “I once asked him when we first started dating if he was with me to appease his family, whom he’s very close with, and he said “Kind of” but that he still found me attractive.”
The woman goes on to express her fears that her boyfriend is really gay and eventually will leave her, or that he is transgender and will want to transition later in life. “He sometimes acts effeminate and dresses extremely flamboyantly,” she writes. “I have no problem with people who identify in these ways, but I personally don’t have an interest in being romantically involved with someone who does. I have a very strong sneaking suspicion that he’s biding his time until his parents die or until he decides that he’s going to come out to them as gay.”
Related: Legendary record exec Clive Davis opens up about learning to embrace his bisexuality
How about we take this to the next level?
Our newsletter is like a refreshing cocktail (or mocktail) of LGBTQ+ entertainment and pop culture, served up with a side of eye-candy.
The therapist of The Atlantic empathized with the woman, but pointed out something more glaring. “What strikes me most about your letter, though, is the amount of emotional energy you’re putting into guessing your boyfriend’s state of mind,” the therapist writes. “The more you ruminate about his potential turmoil, the more turmoil you create for yourself. And even as you worry about whether he might be keeping his thoughts from you, you’re also keeping your thoughts from him.”
The problem for the couple then is not the man’s sexuality, but rather a failure to communicate. The therapist encourages open dialogue about gender, family, sex and what the couple wants from their future. “Now’s the time to have these discussions, and you can start by making sure that you broach the topic as a conversation and not as an accusation…You’ll also want to be mindful not to pressure him to take a stance, especially because he may not know how he feels, or he may not be ready to say. The point of these initial conversations will likely be less about getting answers and more about hearing each other.”
Ultimately, the therapist cautions the woman not to jump to conclusions. Homosexuality, bisexuality and transgenderism are not the same thing, and one does not lead to the other. Therefore, the problem isn’t the man’s sexuality but the woman’s insecurity, and the failure of the couple to have real conversations about love and sex. In that way, the lessons apply to all couples: talk about your fears, your problems and your hopes for the future. Sexuality isn’t the issue: communication is!
Dymension
Um, “kinda, but I still find you attractive”? Do you really have to ask people’s opinions about this one?
Josh447
On that note. I’d say the conversation has been had. Move on time.
PLAYS WELL WITH OTHERS
Don’t worry Sister! He is 100% Bi-sexual!
He sleeps with both men and teen boys… :-p
Hussain-TheCanadian
BWAHAHAHAHAHA YOUR COMMENT GOT ME GOOD 🙂
Donston
It doesn’t matter what identities he embraces nor where he fits on the gender, romantic, sexual, affection, relationship spectrum. He already said he resists dating men primarily due to family and religion. You knew what the deal was from the get-go. So, either continue to go with the flow, or move on and tell him him to get the balls to be with and love who he really wants to be with and love.
Donston
I will say that being effeminate or “flamboyant” does not automatically equate to “gay”, but it does frequently at least equates to “queer”. There are plenty of “masculine” homosexual males, and there’s a decent amount of effeminate guys who have overall female preferences and contentment. However, it’s obvious there are things keeping him back from completely being himself, completely being honest and living the life he wants to live.
Jack Meoff
How did this woman not dump him after the ‘Kind of’ answer he gave her. She must be low on prospects herself.
Donston
Maybe she was able to overlook it because she really liked him and was attracted to him, but now that the infatuation/honeymoon stage is over it’s starting to bug her. I would never want to be anyone’s go-to primarily because family, religion, social politics, ego will not allow them to be who they really want to be with. Having some attractions to your gender and perhaps having some type of romantic curiosities in your gender in one thing. Making it clear that you’d rather be with another type of person, that you’d rather receive persistent passions, romantic affections, bonds, comfort, commitment from another type of person but circumstances are holding you back is another thing entirely. But some people are cool with being a consolation prize. In fact, some feel most at home with those dynamics in a relationship.
tdx3fan
Honey, he’s as gay as the day is long, and any good therapist giving advice would have told you to kick his ass to the curb. For the therapist to throw this all back on you is kind of disgusting and run away PC logic.